Two Card-Linked Offers/Rewards Startups Launch at TechCrunch Disrupt

image While I’ve read TechCrunch since its beginning, I’ve only been able to make it to their semi-annual event, Disrupt, once before. It’s usually just too close to our own Finovate. But this year I made the trek to Pier 94 in Manhattan to see what was going on in tech in general and to meet with the fintech startups in the Startup Alley or Battlefield launch competition.

There were six fintech companies in total. Three offered variations on card-linked offers, one has developed an alternative payment system, one was a newer payments gateway, and surprisingly there was just a single crowdfunding platform.  

Startup Battlefield competitors from fintech: TechCrunch selected thirty companies in advance. All have agreed to launch their companies on stage at the event. 

  • imageCardify: Card-linked loyalty/offers geared toward local merchants. Sean Rad is CEO and of the West Hollywood company which has raised $750,000.
  • imageMirth: Same as above. Jeremy Philip Galen is Founder. The NYC-based company is bootstrapped. 

Startup Alley participants from fintech: These are companies less than two years old that qualify for a table in the networking hall. Each day one of the Alley companies is voted to the stage to imagecompete in the Battlefield.

  • LocalBonus: A card-linked offers platform focusing on the local market
  • imagePayintele: An alt-payments company using barcodes to pass info between merchant and payee (I’ll do a whole post on them shortly)image
  • PayLeap: A payments gateway from two previous Authorize.net execs
  • The Crowd Funds: A crowdfunding startup from former image E*Trade CTO, Joshua Levine

Observations: It was interesting to see three new card-linked rewards companies all going after the local market. But if you look at what Groupon’s done with local merchants and where Square is headed, you can see there are huge opportunities here.

And the payment APIs available from Cardspring (which both Mirth and Cardify use) are making it relatively easy for startups to tap into a merchant’s card transaction streams to make offers, tally rewards, identify frequent customers, and communicate with them.

As a side note, Cardify has a gorgeous UI. It’s very hip and high-end looking like something you’d see at more well-funded companies such as Square, Simple or Mint (screenshot below). Kudos to the design folk there.

———

Cardify homepage (24 May 2012)

cardify app as seen on its homepage

—————————-

Notes:
1. While not a fintech company, as an auction junkie, I was intrigued by Outbid’s social mobile/online auction platform. The company said it’s talking to four banks looking to host live auctions on their site to use for promotions and social gaming. I think it’s a promising idea, one I’ve explored a few times over the years. But with Facebook Connect you can actually get a critical mass of customers involved very quickly. The company had the cheesiest demo I’ve ever seen (and that’s saying something), but that shouldn’t impact your decision.

How DCisions, Personal Capital, SigFig, FutureAdvisor, and Jemstep Are Shaking Up Wealth Management

The wealth management industry has seen increased press coverage lately. Take, for example, The Economist’s recent piece discussing how increased competition from startups has tempted clients into moving assets to lower-cost alternatives.

The article mentions DCisions, a startup tackling the big data around client portfolios. It also highlights Personal Capital, which launched at FinovateFall. The Economist states that the startup’s online platform:

DCisionsLogo.jpgThumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for PersonalCapitalLogo.jpg

“… tries to straddle the world between cheap online wealth management and the old world of private banking”

Aside from the cost, one of the largest benefits of moving your 
millions into a startup like Personal Capital is that the investment advice is unbiased. This is a topic that Business Insider covered last week, voicing concerns that clients’ brokers are “royally screwing them over.”

The article states:

WealthMgmt.jpg

“With no other fees to compare your own to, you could wind up paying for far more than you should – especially if your broker’s working on commission.”

To ease this concern, the article recommends using
DIY tools such as SigFig, FutureAdvisor, or Jemstep. These tools help you see how your funds are performing and how much you’re paying in fees.

To learn more about these companies, watch DCisions’ FinovateEurope 2012 demo, Personal Capital’s FinovateFall 2011 demo, SigFig’s FinovateFall 2011 demo, FutureAdvisor’s FinovateSpring 2012 demo (coming soon), or Jemstep’s FinovateSpring 2010 demo

Finovate Alumni News– May 23, 2012

  • Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Finovate-F-Logo.jpgArroweye Solutions announces 1Q of 2012 was its largest with 9 new clients & sales of over 2 million cards.
  • Check out this month’s CEO interview with Lending Club’s Renaud Laplanche.
  • ValidSoft partners with Adeptra to power a detection & prevention application that helps mitigate SIM card fraud.
  • eToro announces launch of mobile Trade Alerts app that creates actionable trade notifications.
  • Fast Company considers how Tradeshift could disrupt the banking industry.
  • TechCrunch reports: Wall Street Survivor Gamifies Financial Education With Help From Bunchball.
  • AdvisorOne reports BrightScope to propose universal performance standard for financial advisors.
  • Internet Evolution reports: Dwolla Could Speed Online Payments, If Banks Go Along.
This post will be updated throughout the day as news and developments emerge. You can also follow all the alumni news headlines on the Finovate Twitter account.

CEO Interview: Renaud Laplanche of Lending Club

Thumbnail image for LendingClubLogo.jpg

This month, we interviewed the CEO of Lending Club, Renaud Laplanche, to get a deeper understanding of the peer-to-peer lending platform and the leadership behind it.

Lending Club is a three-time demoing company at Finovate, taking the stage at the first Finovate in 2007, Finovate 2008, and FinovateStartup 2009.

RenaudPic.jpg

Finovate: What’s the biggest hurdle you’ve overcome at Lending Club? 

Laplanche: Lending Club has achieved enormous success–we are now the dominant market leader with 75% market share, issuing over $40 million in loans each month–but the road to success has not been without challenges. One of the biggest hurdles was simply convincing people that lending money to strangers over the Internet could be a safe and profitable way to invest. The challenge was compounded in October 2008 when the near-unprecedented credit crisis hit the country in full force: Would borrowers suffering from job losses and shrinking home values be able to repay the loans?  Would investors experiencing staggering stock market declines be willing to invest in an unproven asset? We tightened our credit policy to focus on borrowers with good to excellent credit, and to generate momentum, I invested a significant amount of my own money to fund the first loans on the platform. These steps worked, and — as we continued to deliver steady returns to investors — Lending Club began attracting capital in record numbers.  

Finovate: How have you dealt with Lending Club’s growth?

Laplanche: We’ve had to move quickly to keep up with the pace, while balancing the borrowing and investing sides of the business. One of the ways we’ve managed growth is by making sure we have the best people in place to drive the company’s continued evolution. For us, that has included recruiting a top-notch executive team with backgrounds in some of the world’s finest financial institutions, as well as creating new roles for valued employees that enable them to thrive, grow and continue contributing to the company’s success.   We more than doubled year-over-year revenue for calendar year 2011, and added over 25 employees in 2011 bringing the company total to 78.

Finovate: How would you compare and contrast Lending Club to Prosper?

Laplanche: As the largest player in the space (75% share of the market), we have a wider breadth of products, and offer investors more liquidity and greater access to inventory. We also focus only on the top 10-20% of borrowers in terms of credit quality, which has allowed us to deliver predictability in the form of 19 consecutive quarters of positive returns.  Our size has allowed us to develop products geared toward larger investors, including funds for accredited investors and separately managed accounts via LC Advisors, our wholly owned subsidiary. We have more of the tools, structures and controls that sophisticated investors expect. 

Finovate: Can you share Lending Club’s most recent user numbers? 

Laplanche: We have have issued more than $600,000,000 in loans to over 50,000 borrowers.  They choose Lending Club because we offer a convenient online process and our rates are 20-30% below traditional alternatives.  The loans have been funded by nearly 80,000 registered investors, ranging from young individuals with a few thousand dollars, to high net worth individuals, family offices, hedge funds and insurance companies with several million dollars on the platform.   

Finovate: What’s the most surprising thing you’ve encountered since launching Lending Club?

Laplanche: That we have managed to successfully grow our platform during the worst recession since the great depression.  At a time when banks stopped lending, mortgages were defaulting at record rates and investors were getting hammered by the market, we managed to continue to issue millions in loans and deliver great results to investors.  We have come out of that period incredibly strong; with a stress tested credit model that is now attracting significant investor capital. 

Finovate: How do you personally use Lending Club? 

Laplanche: I’ve been an investor on the platform since Lending Club’s inception, funding a significant number of the initial loans with my own money to help kick-start the business.

Finovate: How do you ease investor concerns of faulty borrowers? 

Laplanche: The annualized default rate for our Prime Consumer Notes is around 3% — comparable to most banks which make loans to highly credit worthy individuals.  We keep our default rate to a minimum by issuing loans to the most credit worthy individuals – approving less than 10% of all applications — and setting up automatic withdrawals from their bank accounts. When a payment issue occurs, our in-house team reaches out to work with consumers to get back on track. If our efforts fail we turn the loan over to a collections agency.

Finovate: Where do you see Lending Club evolving? 

Laplanche: The market we address is truly staggering at a total $2.4 trillion in consumer credit… so there is no shortage of opportunities for new products and services which would benefit from our efficient model.  Short term, we expect to pass $1 billion in loans originated this year, and will add employees to bring our total headcount more than 100.

Finovate: You’ve won the French sailing championship twice. Are you still able to make time for sailing?

Laplanche: The business keeps me busy, but we do host an annual Lending Club Regatta where we charter several sailboats and stage a race amongst employees.   I am also a member of the St Francis Yacht Club in San Francisco and occasionally steal a day out on the bay with my family.

To learn more about Lending Club, watch its FinovateStartup 2009 demo. Stay tuned for another CEO interview next month.

Finovate Alumni News– May 22, 2012

  • Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Finovate-F-Logo.jpgPersonal Capital updates privacy and security policy.
  • Geezeo signs Westmoreland Community Federal Credit Union.
  • Bobber Interactive adds Scott Rigby, Ph.D, Founder of Immersyve Inc., to its executive team.
  • Mortgagebot launches consumer loan product to automate mortgage & consumer loan origination.
  • Pawtucket Credit Union selects Q2ebanking for ebanking services.
  • Virtual Piggy appoints best-selling author, Stedman Graham, to its board of advisors.
  • MyBankTracker comments on Money Desktop’s integration of Deals into a PFM.
  • Mobile Payments Today looks at the CSI globalVCard.
  • Business2Community looks at Linkable Networks’ technology.
  • Crain’s Chicago Business covers Kabbage’s Social Klimbing.
  • Acculynk announces a UX upgrade to their graphical PIN pad.
  • Luup powers National Bank of Abu Dhabi’s real-time international account-to-account money transfer service via mobile.
  • Figlo wins Best Demo award.
  • SoMoLend wins Startup 2012 business pitch competition.
This post will be updated throughout the day as news and developments emerge. You can also follow all the alumni news headlines on the Finovate Twitter account.

Finovate Alumni News– May 21, 2012

  • Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Finovate-F-Logo.jpgCU Times reports Ensenta & MShift partner in joint mobile banking & RDC deployment at 5 CUs.
  • Pacific Daily News recommends Mint.com Buxfer, or Budgetpulse for new grads to keep track of spending.
  • BankNXT looks at FinovateSpring Best of Show demos and Simple’s new app.
  • Taulia & SAP partner for dynamic discounting services.
  • Seattle’s KOMO News covers BillGuard.
  • Wall Street Journal suggests Mint, Credit Karma, HelloWallet & LearnVest as tools for financial novices.
This post will be updated throughout the day as news and developments emerge. You can also follow all the alumni news headlines on the Finovate Twitter account.

Feature Friday: Universal Checkbook from Personal Capital

imageOne of my favorite features unveiled last week, was Universal Checkbook from Personal Capital. And apparently I wasn’t the only one. Attendees voted the startup Best of Show (again) and hit Twitter with positive comments such as the one below from Brad Leimer (@leimer) of Mechanics Bank,.

Universal Checkbook (see inset) allows users to move money directly between any linked bank/brokerage accounts, providing they have check-writing capabilities.

imageWhile many banks also support interbank transfers, they usually require funds to move in and out of the host bank account. To move money between two third-party accounts requires two separate transfers. And it would take 5 or 6 days (via U.S. ACH system) if you waited for the funds to arrive in the host account before sending them elsewhere. 

In the demo, Personal Capital showed how easy it is to enroll a new bank accounts using deposit capture to grab a check image from that account. However, this enrollment option is not yet available in the production iPhone app (note 2, 3).

Pricing: There is no word on pricing, but it looks like there may be a fee eventually. On the bottom of the pay screen it says, "Try Universal Checkbook FREE for three months!" Because Personal Capital offers basic PFM services ad- and fee-free, it will likely need fees for money movement, at least for users not committing any assets to the startup.

————————–

Tweet from Bradley Leimer (@leimer) during Personal Capital demo at FinovateSpring (8 May 2012)

image 

————
Notes:
1. We took an in-depth look at truly virtual banks (Personal Capital, Bank Simple, and PerkStreet) in our Oct 2011 Online Banking Report.
2. The app doesn’t yet explain how to enroll new payment accounts, evidently the image capture capability is still in process.
3. Universal Checkbook has not yet been incorporated into Personal Capital’s iPad or desktop versions.

Finovate Alumni News– May 18, 2012

Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Finovate-F-Logo.jpg

  • Business Insider examines how SigFig, JemStep, and FutureAdvisor can help manage your investments.
  • Work Goes Strong recommends using Planwise to help get out of debt.
  • Huffington Post interviews Bill Harris, Personal Capital CEO.
This post will be updated throughout the day as news and developments emerge. You can also follow all the alumni news headlines on the Finovate Twitter account.

Finovate Alumni News– May 17, 2012

  • Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Finovate-F-Logo.jpgSoMoLend raises $1.17 in Seed Funding.
  • TradeKing and Zecco announce agreement to merge.
  • The Economist names CurrencyFair as an option for transferring money abroad.
  • The Economist looks at how Wonga, Mint, SaveUp, and ReadyForZero use Big Data.
  • Xconomy reports Kony Solutions receives $15 mil in Series C financing.
  • Finextra reports SafetyPay takes e-commerce cash payment service global.
This post will be updated throughout the day as news and developments emerge. You can also follow all the alumni news headlines on the Finovate Twitter account.

Lock in Your Seat for FinovateFall 2012 by May 18th and Save $300!

btn3_ov.png

Last week in San Francisco, we hosted our largest Finovate event ever with almost 1,200 innovators watching the cutting-edge of fintech debut live.

It was an incredible gathering that showcased new launches in everything from payments to mobile to security to investing to offers and much more (demo videos will be up soon).

Amazingly, based on our initial projections, this September’s FinovateFall in New York City promises to beat last week’s record attendance and create an unrivaled gathering of the leading entrepreneurs, executives and investors in the financial technology space. 

To lock in your spot in this fall’s record-setting audience at the maximum savings, please get your ticket soon. If you buy your ticket before this Friday (May 18th), you’ll save $300 via the super early-bird price.

We hope to see you this fall!

FinovateFall 2012 is sponsored by: The Bancorp Inc., the law firm of Hudson Cook & Tier One Partners

FinovateFall 2012 is partners with: BankInnovation, BankerStuff, Benzinga, Celent, Filene, Finance on Windows & PYMNTS.com

FinovateFall 2012 — Lock in Your Seat by Friday May 18th and Save $300!

btn3_ov.png

Last week in San Francisco, we hosted our largest Finovate event ever with almost 1,200 innovators watching the cutting-edge of fintech debut live.

It was an incredible gathering that showcased new launches in everything from payments to mobile to security to investing to offers and much more (demo videos will be up soon).

Amazingly, based on our initial projections, this September’s FinovateFall in New York City promises to beat last week’s record attendance and create an unrivaled gathering of the leading entrepreneurs, executives and investors in the financial technology space. 

To lock in your spot in this fall’s record-setting audience at the maximum savings, please get your ticket soon. If you buy your ticket before this Friday (May 18th), you’ll save $300 via the super early-bird price.

We hope to see you this fall!

FinovateFall 2012 is sponsored by: The Bancorp Inc., the law firm of Hudson Cook & Tier One Partners

FinovateFall 2012 is partners with: BankInnovation, BankerStuff, Benzinga, Celent, Filene, Finance on Windows & PYMNTS.com

Citibank Helps Users Better Understand Prior Payment Activity When Paying Credit Card Bill Online

image As I was paying my Citibank business credit card bill last night, apparently one day late (oops again), I noticed three new data fields to the payment summary box (note 1):

  • Dollar amount of payments in process as of today from any channel(note 2)
  • Number of payments made online this statement period
  • Dollar amount of payments made online this statement period

Consumers often forget whether they’ve paid the bill or not, so it’s important to provide help so they needn’t click around the site, or worse, call customer service.

While I love the functionality, the bank could have been a bit clearer in language used. For example, I don’t think real people call their credit card payment a "payment request." While that term satisfies the legal folk, who I’m sure argued that it’s only a "request" until the money actually arrives, it’s not consumer-friendly language and the bank does not provide an explanation.

Lastly, there’s an unfortunate lag in the updating of the "payment in progress" field. Immediately after paying my $30.80 statement balance, it shows up in the "online payment requests" field, but not in the "payment in progress" (see first screenshot). A day later, everything was in sync (second screenshot).

Despite these drawbacks, it’s a good improvement in transparency, and every issuer should offer similar info.

————

Citibank online credit card system (16 May 2012)
Note: This screenshot was taken after I’d paid the statement balance, so the "requests" fields shows 1 payment for $30.80. Unfortunately, "The Total Payments in Progress" did not reflect that yet, a confusing misalignment of posting times. 

Citibank online payment info box

Payment info box a day later (17 May 2012)
Note: Now the dollar amount in both fields match up.

Closeup of Citibank online credit card payment box

——-

Note:
1. To be honest, I’m not sure how long this data has been available. It’s possible the bank has been showing it for a long time and I just hadn’t noticed. Perhaps someone from Citi will comment and I’ll update the post.
2. The exact explanation of this field from the Citi help popup:

This is the total amount of payments that you have recently submitted that have not yet posted to your account. This amount includes payments made through: Online Bill Pay, AutoPay or Pay by Phone. Please Note: Any payment made on a weekend or holiday will be applied as of the day you make it. However, it will not be posted until the next business day. Any payment scheduled to be applied for a future date is not included.