The Simple Finance Game or “Hiding PFM in Plain Sight”

image I’ve written thousands and thousands of words about personal finance management (PFM) including seven deep dives in our Online Banking Report (see note 1) and 130 131 blog posts. However, I’ve never articulated the behavioral aspects as well as NY Times software developer Andre Behrens who pens the occasional post at NYTimes.com.

In his Tuesday article, Gamification Done Right, he uses (Bank) Simple as an example of a great use of game mechanics:

Simple.com is the most beautiful bank site I’ve ever seen…but aesthetics are just a baseline. Because what Simple actually wants to do is get you to play a game. The game is called “Master Your Finances”….

HPFM lite: Bank Simple safe-to-spend balancee then describes a key part of this game, which Netbanker readers will recognize as Simple’s Safe-to-Spend balance:

If there’s one number you’re guaranteed to see on a bank site, it’s your balance…I take this number for granted…what other number could there be? But once you start playing the Simple Game, you realize this is a number that matters to the bank much more than it matters to you. What you care about is how much money you can use right now.

He goes on to write about how Simple encourages users to keep savings in unique buckets associated with goals:

…saving has always felt to me like denying myself fun spending opportunities. In the Simple Game, the opposite has proven true. Because every goal has a name and a committed plan, and because the transactions are presented in small increments, saving has become an anticipatory pleasure.

Bottom line: Read the whole article. It may help reinvigorate your efforts to infuse basic PFM concepts directly into everyday online/mobile banking. Every customer should be able to reach the first level of the finance game simply by logging in. How do you take it to the next level? That sounds like the makings of post #132, 133, 134 …..

——————————-

Note:
The OBR PFM library consists of three reports penned a decade ago on account aggregation, the PFM enabling technology pioneered primarily by Yodlee. Then four reports in the modern PFM era looking at features, benefits and bundles (subscription required):
— June 2012: PFM 4.0 here
— May 2010: PFM 3.0 here
— June 2007: Social Personal Finance here
— Aug 2006: Personal Finance Features for Online Banking here
— July 2003: Account Aggregation 3.0 here
— Aug 2000: Account Aggregation 2.0 here
— Oct 1999: Account Aggregation

Op Ed: MRI Study Finds Consumer Interest in Fee-Based Bundles

by Dr. Dan Geller

Dr. Geller is EVP of Market Rates Insight, which provides competitive research and analytics to financial institutions. He can be reached at dan.geller@marketratesinsight.com.

——————————-

imageOne of the most significant findings from our  latest study on banking fee-revenue optimization (see note 1 below) is that the majority of consumers say they will pay monthly subscription fees for value-added financial services (see chart below and list right).

The average monthly fee that more than half (55%) of consumers are willing to pay ranges from $2.17 to $5.06 per month for each service. Of course, these stated amounts are an indication of relative perceived value rather than a pricing guide.

Furthermore, we found that consumers are willing to pay a higher overall monthly fee for the bundle than they would for each of the services individually. For example, study respondents indicated they are willing to pay $3.07 per month for a credit score report, $2.43 for account alerts and $4.27 for prepaid card for a total of $9.77. However, when the three were offered as a bundle, respondents valued them at $10.51, an 8% premium.

Bottom line: We believe there is a path for financial institutions to move customers "from free to fee" by bundling services in the optimal way.  

—————————-

Chart: Consumer Interest in Value-Added Banking Services

image 
Source: Market Rates Insight, June 2013

——————————

Note:
1. For more info on these finding, MRI is offering a free webinar on Tuesday June 18 from 2:00 PM to 3:00 PM Eastern Time. Click here to reserve your space. The full report will be available for purchase beginning June 21 at <marketratesinsight.com>.

Encap Earns Seven-Figure Investment from ProVenture Seed

ENCAPLogo_Orange.jpg

Exact terms of the funding were not disclosed in Encap’s press release of the announcement. However, TechCrunch is reporting that the funding totaled $2 million.

This takes Encap’s total funding to more than $2.8 million, courtesy of previous investment from Alliance Ventures.

Based in Oslo, Norway, Encap specializes in mobile authentication, providing in-app, banking grade security. Encap’s technology eschews SMS codes, hardware tokens, and one-time, password-based authentication in favor of an approach that, in the words of ProVenture Seed Managing Partner, Herbjøm Skjervold, combines multi-factor authentication with risk profiling.
The company plans to use the capital to help expand into new regions, particularly the United States and United Kingdom, as well as to increase market share in a competitive market for security services. According to a report in SecureID News, the multi-factor authentication market itself should surpass $5 billion by 2017.
Encap demoed its technology as part of the FinovateSpring 2013 event in May. See the company’s presentation here.

Finovate Alumni News– June 13, 2013

  • Finovate-F-Logo.jpgZopa Safeguard now has 15,000 users and has had £16m lent on platform. Zopa reaches £300m in money lent to borrowers in the UK.
  • Bank Innovation reports: Cardlytics Has 33 Million Active Users at 400 Banks.
  • Inc. Magazine creates infographic of how to select the right crowdfunding platform. Bolstr and SeedInvest among choices.
  • CommunityLend’s FinanceIt partners with Pivotal Payments, a credit card payment processing company, to enable merchants to process loans directly at the POS.
  • Capital Access Network opens new facility in Lindora, Costa Rica to support growth.
  • Finect president Jennifer Openshaw talks networking for financial professionals on MarketWatch Radio.
  • Street Fight Mag includes Placecast among its “5 Tools for Point of Interest Geo-Targeting”.
  • TransferWise launches GetPaid to make it easier to get compensated when working with international clients and partners.
  • Developer Tech features Keynote Systems’ CEO Umang Gupta.
  • Point of Sale highlights Finovate alumni Flint Mobile and PayPal.
  • Social Trading Guru reviews ayondo 3.0.
This post will be updated throughout the day as news and developments emerge. You can also follow all the alumni news headlines on the Finovate Twitter account.

Locaid Closes $4 Million in New Funding

Thumbnail image for LocaidLogo3.jpg

FinovateFall 2012 alum Locaid just completed a $4.05 million Series D funding round according to VentureBeat.

Participating in the round were InterSouth Partners, H.I.G. Ventures, and Florida Growth Fund, as well as additional investors. The new funding puts Locaid’s total at just north of $30 million.

Founded in 2005, and now with offices in both Boca Raton and San Francisco, Locaid specializes in Location-as-a-Service (LaaS) solutions ranging from IP and Landline location to geofencing and location analytics.
locaidhomepage2.jpg
Locaid’s “footprint” extends to more than 4 billion connected devices worldwide, including more than 400 million mobile devices. The company is also the largest location gateway for major carriers such as AT&T, Sprint, and Verizon. Locaid made headlines earlier this month with the release of its Compliance API.
To see Locaid’s FinovateFall 2012 presentation, visit the company’s demo page here.

Finovate Alumni News– June 12, 2013

  • Finovate-F-Logo.jpgSan Diego County Credit Union launches Cardlytics’ card-linked marketing platform.
  • Newfination: Bill Harris talks about Personal Capital’s new funding round and the issue of continuity.
  • SecureKey’s briidge.net DNA security software and authentication service have been integrated with MasterCard’s MasterPass.
  • BellaDati selects Chicago as its U.S. Headquarters.
  • CEO and co-founder of OpenCoin, Chris Larsen, writes about Bitcoin and “the future of money.”
  • Mint, BudgetPulse listed among budgeting options in column on digitizing your finances.
  • DigitalMailer signs technology and marketing partnership with CoreTrack.
  • Locaid closes $4 million funding round.
  • DeviceFidelity partners with Susan G. Komen Dallas County via moneto Prepaid MasterCard program.
This post will be updated throughout the day as news and developments emerge. You can also follow all the alumni news headlines on the Finovate Twitter account.

TD Bank Launches Dynamic Login Page

image It’s no secret that a first-time online banking visitor has far different needs than the power user returning for login #1,712. But most banking sites provide the same visual login treatment for all users.

That forces new users to search out buried "getting started" or "register" links. Or they will make time-consuming, and expensive, phone calls to customer service for guidance.

And the one-size-fits-all approach is not optimal for experienced users either. As they skim by the static boilerplate in the banking version of banner blindness, power users miss the chance to learn more about new features and promotions.

The new design unveiled last week (4 June 2013; see old look in last screenshot below) from TD Canada Trust aims to solve both problems: 

  • After selecting login on the homepage, new users are shown a page with prominent help on how to get started along with links to register, take a tour, get help and so on (see first screenshot below).
  • Previously logged in visitors see a page featuring a banner below the login box emphasizing a single online banking feature and contextual links on the right (see second screenshot).

Bottom line: I like the concept. And eventually the bank can segment even tighter showing different looks for intermediate users, mobile-primary customers, French-speaking customers, and so on. Even in this first iteration, TD could make it better by:

  • Greeting/welcoming the customer
  • Providing more detailed instructions (e.g. What’s the optional "description" box for?, Why are they asking for access card number or username?)
  • Adding more graphical emphasis to draw the user’s attention

For reference, see how Chase Bank handles new and existing visitors.

——————————————

TD Canada Trust login page: First-time user (4 June 2013)
Note: Getting started info placed in right column

TD Bank login page: new user

TD Canada Trust login page: Existing user
Note: Online banking tips are displayed under the login box and contextual links are shown on right, in this case a link to the mobile app

TD Canada Trust login page: Existing user

Previous login page (3 June 2013)

Previous login page prior to june 4 2013

ayondo Launches in the United Kingdom

Thumbnail image for ayondoLogo.jpg

ayondo’s European expansion just reached another border, as the company announces that it has launched its social trading service in the UK.

Based in Frankfurt, Germany, ayondo is an innovator in the world of social trading. The company’s platform allows average investors to share trades and investments and, more importantly, to trade and invest alongside the best performing traders and investors on the platform.

Those using ayondo can trade a variety of assets, including currencies, stock market indices, individual stocks, and commodities. Traders can begin following up to 5 top traders for a little as €100.

ayondohomepage.jpgThat ayondo would expand to the UK should probably come as little surprise. The company had already expressed its interest in the UK and Irish markets by adding spread betting to the platform earlier this year. Spread betting is available only to ayondo’s clients living in Ireland or the UK.

Said ayondo managing director Thomas Winkler in a press release, “ayondo is the first social trading platform to offer spread betting with proportional following for a wide range of asset classes.”
ayondo was founded in 2008, and launched its social trading platform in January 2012. The company demoed its technology as part of the FinovateEurope show a year later in London. See  the company’s presentation here.

Intellaegis’ masterQueue Technology Helps Catch Wanted Fugitive

intellaegis_logo.jpg

There are many ways to describe the innovators in financial technology.

And thanks to Intellaegis, we can add “fugitive catcher” to the list.

The El Dorado Country District Attorney’s office in California sought out the services of hometown technology company, Intellaegis, to help them find an elusive fugitive who had been on the run for years.
Watch the news report from the CBS Sacramento affiliate.
According to the report, masterQueue was able to track the fugitive’s data footprints as she traveled across the country to states as distant as Michigan, California, and Florida. The fugitive had been on the run for three years. masterQueue was able to track her down in five minutes.
Intellaegis was founded in 2009 and is headquartered in El Dorado Hills, California. The company debuted masterQueue in 2011 as part of FinovateSpring in San Francisco. See the company’s presentation here.

Finovate Alumni News– June 11, 2013

Finovate-F-Logo.jpg

  • miiCard partners with authentication company, Toopher, to help users and businesses more effectively fight fraud and secure new services online.
  • BBVA Compass deploys Mitek’s Mobile Photo Bill Pay.
  • TIBCO Software acquires StreamBase Systems.
  • Kofax issued patent that covers sending receipt confirmation for a fax.
  • AU Arts Hub profiles Narrative Science’s approach to journalism.
  • Cashstar announces patent for virtual gift card technology.
  • Keynote brings MITE Enterprise, DeviceAnywhere Enterprise to UFT users.
  • Green Dot to acquire Walmart’s reloadable prepaid card business, MoneyCard.
  • Affinity Solutions raises more than $21 million.
This post will be updated throughout the day as news and developments emerge. You can also follow all the alumni news headlines on the Finovate Twitter account.

Affinity Solutions Raises More than $21 Million

Thumbnail image for AffinityLogo2.jpg

With its latest round of funding, Affinity Solutions’ total financing tops $40 million.

This latest funding round was led by Massachusetts-based private equity firm, Chestnut Hill Ventures. The firm specializes in the commercial marketing and financial services industries, and provided more than $14 million in equity financing for Affinity Solutions a year ago.

Affinity Solutions says that the $21 million will go towards helping the company bring its marketing platform to market. Affinity Solutions currently has partnerships with more than 4,000 financial institutions, and more than 25,000 brick and mortar retail outlets.
This latest round of funding was a big jump up from the company’s most recent capital-raising effort: $6.75 million raised in February via a combined equity/convertible securities offering.
All told, Affinity Solutions’ fundraising over the past year:
  • $14.5 million in equity financing – June 2012
  • $6.75 million in equity/convertible financing – February 2013
  • $21+ million in funding – June 2013
Headquartered in New York, Affinity Solutions presented its technology at FinovateSpring in San Francisco in 2012. See the company in action here.

Finovate Alumni News– June 10, 2013

  • FinovateLOGO.jpgThe Oakland Tribune’s Inside Bay Area profiles OneID founder and CTO Steve Kirsch.
  • EZBOB adds variable lengths, longer periods, lower interest, and loyalty discounts on its loans.
  • Realty Mogul co-founder and CEO Jilliene Helman talks crowdfunding and real estate investing.
  • MicroStrategy business intelligence solution, MicroStrategy Express named a finalist at 2013 American Business Awards.
  • Newfination interviews Jilliene Helman, co-founder and CEO of Realty Mogul.
  • SF Gate blog looks at Personal Capital, Wealthfront, and FutureAdvisor.
  • Newfination interviews Kristoffer Lawson, Holvi CEO, on replacing your bank with Holvi.
  • Mortgagebot launches MortgageMarvel site to help consumers shop for mortgages.
  • CNET interviews Lending Club CEO Renaud Laplanche on recent funding and future growth.
  • Bloomberg BusinessWeek takes a look at the business of Google Wallet.
  • Money Under 30 reviews TradeKing.
  • Intellaegis’s masterQueue technology helps catch wanted fugitive.
This post will be updated throughout the day as news and developments emerge. You can also follow all the alumni news headlines on the Finovate Twitter account.