Target Fee-Based Security & Control Packages to Small Business Owners

image A few days ago we published a new Online Banking Report: Delivering that Secure Feeling, arguing for the creation of fee-based subscription packages for those that need more security/privacy assurance than the typical consumer.

What we probably should have made clearer is that this is NOT a product strategy for the mass market. It’s geared toward high-end, wealthier customers and/or businesses that have a lot more to lose if their accounts are compromised.

The need for more security is especially acute for the small business owner, especially larger small businesses keeping five- and six-figure balances, sharing account access with accountants, bookkeepers, and partners, while making 100s of transactions per month.

In addition, business accounts generally operate without Federal consumer protections, so fraud losses may have to be absorbed by the business, unless they can prove negligence by financial institution. Litigating a major fraud loss is an ugly situation that should be avoided if at all possible.

That’s why it’s a win-win-win when a biz-banking client pays a fee for extra fraud protection:

  • Biz customers have fewer worries
  • Bank profits from the fee-based service
  • Fewer unreimbursed fraud losses save both parties time, money and potentially massive ill will

Take it from this small-biz owner. For 15+ years I have wished for more security/control and would be more than happy to pay for it, really! (see note 1). Every single day I dread opening the multiple email alerts from my biz bank afraid that one day I will join the the small but growing number of biz owners that have had their accounts looted (note 2).

Commercial customers have sophisticated tools at their disposal, but the smaller biz is often left using consumer-type controls. This is not how it should be.

———————–

Notes:
1. I’ve long said that I’d be willing to pay $500/mo for the perfect package of online business banking, payment, bookkeeping, and customer-management services. I stand by that statement (though I’d probably pay even more now that we have more international issues with the Finovate event). See our Online Bankin Report on micro and small businesses for more info.
2. Here’s one of the paradoxes of more communications, more “worry events.” In the past, I would have only dreaded opening my statement once per month. Now I have that little pit in my stomach several times each day. That doesn’t seem right.
3. Image licensed from Shutterstock.

Mobile Banking & Payments by the Numbers

Statement rewards provider and BillShrink parent, Truaxis, published a nice summary of mobile banking and payments on its blog (reprinted with permission below).

A few Industry Players metrics at the bottom of the infographic have recently been updated:

  • Starbucks said this week it has processed 42 million mobile payments, up from 26 million (Venture Beat, 9 April 2012)
  • Square has now shipped 1 million readers, up from 500,000; and is now processing $11 million per day, up from $4 mil (Splatf, 5 March 2012)

Mobile banking & payment infographic

MoneyDesktop Adds 19 Credit Union Clients

Thumbnail image for MoneyDesktopLogo.jpg

Yesterday MoneyDesktop, financial management tool developer, announced the addition of 19 Credit Union clients. 

The new clients will use MoneyDesktop’s PFM solution to bring their members the money management solution within their online banking platform.

Below is the list of newly added clients:

  • Day Air Credit Union
  • Cumberland County Federal Credit Union
  • San Antonio Citizens Federal Credit Union
  • Peninsula Federal Credit Union
  • Achieve Financial Credit Union
  • Torrance Community Federal Credit Union
  • AAC Credit Union
  • Tomah Area Credit Union
  • Ukrainian Selfrelaince New England Federal Credit Union
  • Spirit of America Federal Credit Union
  • Health Employees Federal Credit Union
  • Evergreen Credit Union
  • Omaha Douglas Federal Credit Union
  • Family Focus Federal Credit Union
  • Northern Paper Mills Credit Union
  • Air Guard Federal Credit Union
  • Newaygo County Service Employees Credit Union
  • Oshkosh Truck Credit Union
  • Northern Teachers Community Credit Union

This brings the Utah-based startup’s total number of clients up to over 260.

To learn more about MoneyDesktop, come see its FinovateSpring 2012 demo in San Francisco on May 8 and 9. Get your ticket here.

Finovate Alumni News– April 10, 2012

  • Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Finovate-F-Logo.jpgCredit Karma is moving its headquarters to San Francisco’s financial district.
  • Linkable Networks is listed as 1 of 5 startups you should follow.
  • Tablet PC review lists Wikinvest Portfolio as one of the best iPad apps for tracking Wall Street stocks.
  • AOL Daily Finance names HelloWallet as 1 of 5 money-smart apps for business travelers.
  • UNC’s Kenan-Flagler Business School turns to Ping Identity to solve identity management complexity.
  • Daily Herald looks at Credit Sesame.
  • Kony Solutions appoints Harold Goldberg as CMO.
  • The Bellingham Herald recommends using Expensify to organize your expenses for tax time. Come see the live demo at FinovateSpring next month in San Francisco.
  • Scotsman covers UK P2P company, Zopa.
  • CNN Money lists SecondMarket as 1 of 8 crowdfunding sites to watch.
This post will be updated throughout the day as news and developments emerge. You can also follow all the alumni news headlines on the Finovate Twitter account.

Launching: SmarterBank, a Virtual Bank Aimed at Student Loan Holders

image Startups are advised to find pain-points, then build businesses to profitably solve them. Despite the current wave of very bad publicity around banks, especially the big ones, everyday banking isn’t a huge pain-point for the 80% of households currently served by existing players.

Sure, I’d like to have more security options, fewer unintelligible messages, and a Cash Tank. But most of these are feature/function improvements, not “must-have” issues that need to be solved.

What are the acute pain points in banking and personal finance?

  • Debt management, especially credit card and student loans
  • Home financing
  • Small business financing
  • Insurance
  • Retirement planning/saving

Three of these five have to do with the debt side of the consumer’s balance sheet. Yet, much of the talk about online/mobile banking innovations centers around spending management, payments, checking and savings accounts, and account access technology.

So I get pretty excited about innovations on the debt front. And last week, there was an interesting launch on the student-loan-management front, SmarterBank from Finovate alum, SimpleTuition. Its tagline says it all:

Smarterbank is "the bank that helps you pay down your student loans"

It’s a truly free, full-featured checking account, with debit card, paper checks and all the usual (but no branches, of course). And it’s powered by The Bancorp Bank, which has its hands in many of the new direct banking initiates we are seeing, including (bank) Simple.

But the special sauce is a built-in rewards program tied directly into student loan payback.

___________________________________________________________

How it works
___________________________________________________________

It’s actually two separate accounts, rewards and checking. You don’t need to buy the checking account to participate in the rewards program. But you must be in the rewards program before you can get a SmarterBank checking account.

  • SmarterBucks: rewards piece (see first two screenshots below)
  • SmarterBank: the checking account

Users accumulate cash to accelerate student-loan payback in three ways:

  • Deals/offers (note 2)
  • Banking rewards (from linked SmarterBank checking account)
  • Direct contributions from family and friends

SmarterBucks dashboard (8 April 2012)
Note: (1) Link to SmarterBank in upper right
(2)The deals piece is marked “coming soon”

SmarterBuck dashboard with link to SmarterBank from SimpleTuition

SmarterBucks reward activity
SmarterBucks rewards activity screen from SimpleTuition

_________________________________________________________

Sign-up process
_________________________________________________________

1. Sign up for SmarterBucks, which as a non-financial account requires only name and email address

2. Add a student loan that SmarterBucks rewards are credited to

3. (Optional) Add a SmarterBank account so that non-PIN debit purchases earn SmarterBucks rewards

4. (Optional) Invite family to contribute money directly to the SmarterBucks account

SmarterBank application hosted by The Bancorp Bank (link)

Smarterbank application powered by The Bancorp Bank

______________________________________________________________

Analysis
________________________________________________________________

Marrying rewards, checking/debit, P2P family contributions, and student loan repayment is brilliant. It not only provides a tangible benefit for the 37 million Americans with student loan debt (see note 1), but also is a great customer-acquisition tool for a very important segment, recent college grads. Financial institutions looking for more twenty-something customers should consider building similar capabilities or partnering with SimpleTuition.

———-

Notes:
1. Figures are from the company. It also said that 10 million students owe more than $50,000, and 2 million owe more than $100,000.
2. Friends and family will also be able to link their own SmarterBucks account to the student’s.
3. We covered family/student banking nine months ago in our Online Banking Report (here).

cbanc Network Acquires Webinar Company, Bankerstuff

Thumbnail image for cbancLogo.jpg

Collaborative information-sharing platform, cbanc Network, announced last week that it has acquired financial webinar and education company, Bankerstuff.

For cbanc Network, this is a great strategic move. According to a recent survey of the cbanc community:

“88% of respondents are “somewhat” or “highly” likely to buy webinars from cbanc, where those users already spend time collaborating with their peers to solve industry issues.”

Through this partnership, cbanc’s 9,300+ banking and credit union professionals will have access to purchase Bankerstuff’s online inventory of ongoing educational webinars. Bankerstuff’s 7,000 customers will benefit from the partnership by receiving an incentive to join cbanc’s collaborative community and the company now:

1) Has access to more resources and staff to deliver a broader scope of webinars, topics, and speakers. 

2) Has access to behind-the-scenes financial data from the cbanc community

Bankerstuff.jpg

Webinars will still be accessed through the Bankerstuff website for the foreseeable future. On the right is a glimpse of Bankerstuff’s updated logo.

To learn more about cbanc Network, come see it demo live at FinovateSpring in San Francisco May 8-9. Get your ticket here. Or watch its demo from FinovateFall 2011.

Finovate Alumni News– April 9, 2012

  • Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Finovate-F-Logo.jpgCashSherpa.com reviews FutureAdvisor.
  • SuccessStories.com features Alexa Von Tobel, LearnVest CEO.
  • MyBankTracker reports TIO Networks gives underbanked a mobile wallet. See TIO Networks demo live at FinovateSpring next month.
  • Wisconsin State Journal features TASCET, who will demo its Financial Iconn technology at FinovateSpring in San Fran, May 8-9.
  • Northwest Credit Union Association reports Oregon Employees FCU is piloting SaveUp’s prize-linked savings alternative. See them at FinovateSpring.
  • Business Insider names Yodlee and Andera as 2 of 5 faceless companies that control your money.
  • MSNBC consults BillGuard to determine the validity of certain questionable charges. See them demo at FinovateSpring.
  • Financial Planning takes a closer look at Balance Financial.
This post will be updated throughout the day as news and developments emerge. You can also follow all the alumni news headlines on the Finovate Twitter account.

Finovate Alumni News– April 6, 2012

  • Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Finovate-F-Logo.jpgInComm removes Visa Gift Card & MasterCard Gift Card products from New Jersey stores due to regulation.
  • SimpleTuition launches Student-Friendly SmarterBank, Powered by The Bancorp Bank.
  • Clairmail introduces Clairmail Plus, a mobile banking & payments solution for midmarket FIs. 
This post will be updated throughout the day as news and developments emerge. You can also follow all the alumni news headlines on the Finovate Twitter account.

New Online Banking Report Published: Delivering that Secure Feeling

image OK, let’s think this through. Consumers have been concerned about the security of online banking for more than a decade. Technology tools are available to ease their anxiety. So, why aren’t these tools readily available?

The answer is that most security enhancements don’t pay their own way in terms of reduced fraud. Therefore, these “nice to have” features languish in the priority queue with little hope of getting implemented.

So do we just let customers continue to needlessly fret about the security of their financial accounts?

No, that just irritates already fed-up customers and invites more independent competitors to the table to provide the missing benefits (e.g., BillGuard, Credit Karma, Mint).

Instead, why not move to the win-win solution: Charge an optional subscription fee for extra “peace of mind,” but only to customers who want it. Or offer the value-adds free of charge for customers who help you lower costs by using self-service channels and foregoing printed statements.  

But wait. Aren’t fees dead after the BofA debacle a few months ago?

While that was a very real customer backlash, optional fees are still possible. Just keep these rules in mind:

  • Fees for extra security should NEVER be mandatory; instead, offer a “security bundle” that goes above and beyond the normal state of the art
  • Do not charge a fee for any security feature you already offer free of charge (the big problem with the ill-fated debit card monthly fee)
  • Do not charge for a security feature that is typically delivered free of charge by others in the industry
  • It’s better to bundle a group of extra security features into a relative low-priced subscription bundle

In our new 48-page report we cover:

  • 12 design elements to make your website feel more secure
  • 7 potential positive elements for your business case
  • 5 talking points for staff education before implementing a subscription fee
  • 37 potential security enhancements to bundle into an “extra security” subscription offering
  • 72 additional security features to consider
  • 5 customer segments to target with a fee-based package account
  • Overview of three promising security services:
    — Anti-virus for transactions from BillGuard
    — Self-service suspicious activity reporting from Bank of America
    — Virtual safe deposit from Northwest FCU, powered by DigitalMailer

__________________________________________________________________

About the report
__________________________________________________________________

Delivering that Secure Feeling (link)
Help consumers reduce perceived risks (for a price)

Author: Jim Bruene, Editor & Founder

Published: 4 April 2012

Length: 48 pages, 8 tables, 12,000 words

Cost: No extra charge to OBR subscribers, US$395 for others here

__________________________________________________________________

Sample screenshot

: Barclays (UK) offers online banking customers free anti-virus software from Kaspersky

clip_image002

SimpleTuition Launches Student-Friendly SmarterBank, Powered by The Bancorp Bank

simpletuitionlogo.jpg

Yesterday, SimpleTuition, a site designed to help students find an ideal student loan, debuted SmarterBank, a student-friendly online bank account that’s powered by The Bancorp Bank.

SmarterBank.jpg

The Bank

SmarterBank, which offers a free checking account that features online banking, bill pay, and a Visa debit card, is designed to help account holders pay back their student loans. It does this by enabling users to set up payments (one-time or recurring) that feed directly to their student loans. It also features a friends and family contribution function that directly pays down the loan with micropayments.

SBDashboard.jpg

The Rewards

Another student-friendly aspect of SmarterBank is SmarterBucks, its free rewards program. Through a partnership with merchant rewards program, RewardsNOW, SmarterBucks enables users to accumulate rewards on everyday purchases that are automatically used to make extra payments on their students loans. This summer, it plans to offer special rewards targeted toward students.

A linked savings account is currently in development and is slated for later this year.

To learn more about SimpleTuition, watch its FinovateStartup 2008 demo.

Finovate Alumni News– April 5, 2012

  • Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Thumbnail image for Finovate-F-Logo.jpgSocial Lending Network reports Prosper quietly adds 3 new search filters.
  • CUinsight reports Credit Union of the Rockies joins SaveUp.
  • VentureBeat looks at PayPal’s new pricing model and suite of mobile products.
  • Money One FCU of Maryland introduces BancVue’s Kasasa.
  • Yodlee launches MoneyMovement, partners with Zoho.
This post will be updated throughout the day as news and developments emerge. You can also follow all the alumni news headlines on the Finovate Twitter account.

FinovateFall 2012 — Apply Now to Demo Your Newest Fintech Innovations in New York City on September 12th & 13th

btn3_ov.png

With FinovateSpring coming up in 4 weeks (please get your ticket before it’s too late) and a ton of buzz about the dozens of innovations that will debut there, you might have missed that we’ve begun accepting demo applications for our flagship FinovateFall conference this September 12th & 13th in New York City.

We’re very excited to be returning to Manhattan again to showcase the best new innovations in fintech right in the heart of the world’s financial capital. Last fall, we hosted our largest Finovate audience ever (over 1,000 executives, investors and entrepreneurs) and this year we expect the audience to grow even more.

If you’d like to apply to demo your latest and great fintech innovation at the event, please email us at [email protected] for more details.

If you want to lock in your ticket now to guarantee your seat, you can register at the affordable pre-sale ticket price through April 13th.

FinovateFall 2012 is sponsored by: The Bancorp Inc., the law firm of Hudson Cook & Tier One Partners

FinovateFall 2012 is partners with: BankInnovation, BankerStuff, Celent, Filene, Finance on Windows & PYMNTS.com