Anatomy of a Webpage: Citibank Business Credit Card

In terms of website design, I find most Citibank pages to be somewhat busy. But overall, the pages usually work well due to the eye-catching graphics, appropriate use of colors, and good copywriting.  

I've had a Citibank Business AAdvantage credit card for at least a decade. Even though I don't visit the site often, maybe once every few months, I find that it's generally easy to find what I'm looking for. 

As you can see in the business card example below, the bank uses purple and green "buttons" to catch your eye, then inserts important key words within them to drive action:

  1. The purple, "Fraud is not your fault" reinforces that customers are not liable for unauthorized transactions, something most people are still concerned about, even though their liability is minimal. The button leads to a page that discusses advanced fraud fighting tools such as virtual account numbers and a picture card.
  2. The navy, "How much have I spent lately?" allows users to quickly drill down into a key area of concern for most card users. Although not as powerful as Wells Fargo's My Spending Report (previous coverage here), it's still a good starting point for many users.
  3. Finally, the bright green, "Help prevent an identity crisis" pitches the bank's credit monitoring solutions (note 1).

Citibank Business Credit Card main account overview page (22 Sep 2007)

Note:

1. For more information on bank and credit union opportunities selling credit report monitoring see our most recent Online Banking Report.

One Last Chance for FINOVATE 2007

Last week, we announced that our Oct. 2 FINOVATE conference was sold out, just a month after it was first announced (here). But while touring the venue Friday, we learned that we could use a nearby 40-person room as an "overflow location." The space is right down the hall from the main auditorium and will carry a live video and audio feed of the DEMOs. Those in the overflow room will have an excellent view of the action on screen and will be able to fully participate in the after-demo networking. 

To join 200+ fellow financial services professionals, register by Thursday, Sep. 27, at our FINOVATE website (click on "register" in the upper-right corner)

Free iPods (again)

I’m not sure why I’m so drawn to the free iPod promotions. Maybe it’s because Citibank never sent me my free one in 2004. Granted, I didn’t jump through all the post-signup hoops, but I’m still sore about it. 

Today, Bank Deals blogged about the latest bank to offer the coveted music player, Plano, Texas-based ViewPoint Bank. This summer (here), I critisized Key Bank and TD Bank for using boring graphics to publicize the sleek device. ViewPoint perhaps does a bit better depending on your tastes (see screenshot below). You certainly can’t miss the promotion, but the bank is still missing an opportunity to showcase the sexy new video nano, rather than the oh-so-2006 version shown in its homepage ad.

The fine print: Like most banks, ViewPoint requires direct deposit to score the music player. And, it must be at least $600/mo, so students take your business elsewhere. But the checking account is free, so the qualifying bar is not set too high. The offer runs through year-end.

One more caveat: If you splash a $150 freebie across the homepage, you better have an answer when your current direct-deposit customers come in for their free iPods as thanks for their ____ years of loyal support. One helpful technique, use cookies so that you don’t even show the offer to existing customers.   

ViewPoint homepage (20 Sep 2007)

FINOVATE 2007 Sold Out

Thanks to Serge Van Dam, Head of Marketing at New Zealand-based M-Com, for purchasing the final seat a few hours ago for our Oct. 2 conference. We look forward to seeing everyone in NYC in 10 days.

We have a wait list forming in case we find a few extra spaces during our walkthrough at the venue tomorrow. Please email, finovate@netbanker.com to add your name to the wait list.

For those not attending in person, there should be plenty of news from the conference. More than 20 members of the media plan to attend including American Banker, The Wall Street Journal, The Financial Times, Money Magazine, Yahoo Finance and more.

We're the first financial services conference to proactively court the blogging community, and we're proud to have bloggers from four countries in the room. Plus, we'll have live blogging here. And soon after the show, all 20 demos will stream from our FINOVATE website.

Thanks again for your support.

Online Banking & Lending Tools at FINOVATE

Much of what we cover at NetBanker falls under the traditional "marketing 4 Ps": product, place, price and package. But, there are also hundreds of important things going on behind the scenes that can make or break a company's Web presence. We are lucky to feature two important tools at our upcoming FINOVATE conference Oct. 2 in NYC.

Online Account Opening from Andera
During the past two years, few areas have received more attention within banks and credit unions than the tricky business of online account opening. It's an absolutely critical element of turning a profit online but also an area rife with risk, error, and the potential for turning away potential new business. We are pleased to have Andera on stage, a company we are seeing more and more of as we drill down through the offerings of major credit unions. The company is a major force in online account opening with more than 125 clients including: Alliant Credit Union, Associated Banc-Corp, General Mills FCU, American First FCU, Toyota Federal Credit Union, First Mid-Illinois Bank & Trust, Energy First Credit Union, CSCEFCU, Service Credit Union, and Bank Rhode Island. Its recent alliance with Yodlee (press release here) opens up even more opportunities. We look forward to seeing its account-opening process in action at FINOVATE.

Web-based Collections from Online Resources
I first met Online Resources in 1992, when its national sales rep visited Seattle to show us their cool smartphone-based banking service. I was new in my R&D assignment looking at alternative delivery methods for US Bancorp, and I really thought there would be a market for this hybrid call center/online banking solution. Of course, that was before the Web burst on the scene three years later. Luckily, Online Resources didn't have all its eggs in the telephony-based basket and adapted quickly to become a leader in Internet banking and electronic payments. The company is a two-time OBR Best of the Web winner, in 2003 once for its novel MoneyHQ premium online banking service and via acquisition of InCurrent which, in 1998, took home one of our first awards for its futuristic online credit card management service. 

At FINOVATE, Online Resources will be showing its Virtual Collection Agent. I have not yet seen it in action, but from the briefing it sounds like a smart way to improve actual collection yields while maintaining the customer relationship during a very tricky time. 

Voice-to-Text Banking

In all the discussions about mobile banking  will it be text-based, go through a mobile website, or do 225 million U.S. mobile phones all have to download some sort of an app there is little discussion on an obvious use case, voice to text.

The only person I've heard talking about this publicly is Richard Crone of Crone Consulting, a fixture on the conference circuit, and the keynoter at SourceMedia's Mobile eCommerce conference in June (see our previous coverage here).

Here's what I want my bank, card company, and credit union to offer (assumes my mobile phone is registered with my bank):

Call my bank's 800 number from my mobile phone, then without touching the keypad, simply say "text me" and hang up (or for multiple account holders, "text me checking," "text me credit card," and so on). Or if background noise is bad or the connection isn't clear, let me press a single number on the first VRU tree that triggers the same text message.

Then, the bank sends me an SMS message with my current and available balance and last ten transactions, or whatever else would fit in the 160 character message. Ideally, I could text back to get more transactions or even make a transfer. But I'll take just the simple one-way message for now.

Would I pay for it? No. But I'm not the core market, since I'm online 24/7. But if I'm a a twenty-something, on the go and managing my account to the last $25 every week, a reasonable fee ($0.25) per message would seem fair. Would it decrease overdraft income? Yep, some. But you'd have a happier customer and potentially some decreased call center expenses.

Zillow Example
While I don't know any banks using this approach, Jott, which is a voice-to-text Web 2.0 company, recently used Zillow's API to offer voice-to-text delivery of home values (see Zillow blog post here). After registering with the sites, users can call Jott, say an address, and receive a text message with the estimated home value of the property. While this is not exactly a mainstream app, it's surely valuable for real estate agents, home buyers, and nosy neighbors.

For more information on this topic read our Mobile Banking & Payments Report.

New Personal Finance Site: Pertuity Direct

Does it seem like every NetBanker blog post lately is a plug for our FINOVATE conference (oops…plug #1)? Hmm … maybe we are a little stuck there.

OK, here's an online personal finance startup that's NOT presenting at FINOVATE (plug #2), Pertuity, the brainchild of ex-PNC Bank exec Kim Muhota. I like the overall look (below), decked out in our FINOVATE colors (plug #3), but clearly it's a placeholder for something more substantive (see note 1).

The Dare to Compare function, while provocatively named, is basically a well-dressed financial calculator that shows you where you stand in terms of income, savings, and debt compared to the rest of the country and those in your age group. It's a nice feature, but hardly unique and certainly not enough to attract visitors, let alone bring them back (see note 2).

UPDATE: After seeing Colin's comment (below), I looked at the site again and realized that I missed the "create a new group" function that allows you to compare your income, savings and debt against other pre-defined subsets. That's an interesting angle and could create a more sticky site with users going back to see how they are growing their income/savings/debt compared to various peer groups. I look forward to seeing how this plays out at Pertuity.

The Rate Survey, Expert Advise, and Blog sections are also just bare-bones link areas with little original content so far. The site appears to have launched just last week, so we are not criticizing (yet), just pointing out the current facts.

The website says "coming in 2008," so we'll be sure to check back in six months and see if they live up to their homepage boast:

….as we gear up towards our launch in early 2008; when we will bring to market a disruptive set of products that will uncomplicate your life, simplify your money and free your dreams.

Note:
1. The homepage has an overall calm look and feel, refreshing for a finance site. But Pertuity needs to lose the clip art of the three scary "suits" in the lower right and enlarge and break up the block of 10-point type in the middle (same goes for the micro-sized font in the blog).

2. Colin Henderson blogged positively about the Dare to Compare feature yesterday (here), but so far anyway, I don't share his enthusiasm that it's "quite revolutionary."  Colin probably has a better crystal ball than I, so I'll reserve judgement until the official launch. (Also, see my update above; obviously, Colin did a better job reviewing the functionality than I.)

Firethorn and Monitise Make Major Announcements

September, October and November are traditionally great months for new product announcements. True to form, at least five major U.S. mobile banking announcements appeared last week. Brandon McGee posts a quick synopsis here.

Of special interest were the announcements by Firethorn/CheckFree and Monitise/Metavante, all of which will be presenting at our upcoming FINOVATE conference in New York City on Oct. 2 (see note 1).

Firethorn
Firethorn ended a relatively quiet stretch with an important announcement, the addition of Ogden, Utah-based America First Credit Union to its mobile banking consortium which includes Wachovia Bank among others (see previous coverage here). The top-10 credit union has more than 400,000 members and gives Firethorn a reference account in the credit union and non-mega-bank categories. The service is expected to go live in early 2008.

We've had the pleasure of hearing the Firethorn story several times, but going into the critical fall marketing period, it will be interesting to hear an update on the Firethorn rollout with AT&T and Verizon Wireless.

Monitise/Metavante Joint Venture
Although disclosed in March of this year, the Monitise and Metavante joint venture was officially announced last week (here). Monitise crosses the Atlantic with mobile banking and payment solutions already widely deployed in its United Kingdom home market under the MONILINK brand. Its client list reads like a who's who of U.K. financial and telecom players: BT Global Services, T-Systems, HSBC, First Direct, Alliance & Leicester, Royal Bank of Scotland, NatWest, Vodafone, Orange, O2, T-Mobile and Hutchison 3G. The JV's Oct. 2 presentation at FINOVATE marks the first time the new entity, Monitise Americas, will be on stage to DEMO the new service expected be available by year-end.

Note:

1. Our FINOVATE 2007 DEMO conference is expected to sell out some time next week, so if you want to reserve a place you should register ASAP at www.finovate.com.

Mint’s Coming-Out Party at TechCrunch 40

Update (8 PM Pacific): Earlier this evening, Mint was named Best Presenting Company at TechCrunch 40 (see here) and took home the $50,000 grand prize. A good first day in the life of the startup!    

Congratulations to Mint on being one of just two financial services startups to win a spot at TechCrunch 40, the tech-startup con-fab in San Francisco that concludes this afternoon. More than 700 companies applied for the presentation slots, and just 40 were chosen. The other financial company was Cake Financial which competes with Zecco, Covestor, and Social Picks, in the "social investing" space, i.e., companies that help users track their investment portfolios and share them with others.

Mint presented in the "Productivity & Web Apps" category this morning and received high marks, scoring a 4.0 out of a possible 5.0 from 67 voters. During the first seven sessions (35 companies), only three have scored higher than 4.0. Mint also received favorable comments from the expert panel comprised of Guy Kawasaki, Esther Dyson, Roelof Botha, and Mike Arrington (blog post here).

For those of you attending our FINOVATE conference Oct. 2 in NYC, you'll have a chance to see a live demo from Mint CEO Aaron Patzer. If you can't wait until then, Mint opened its personal finance app to the public today with a public beta version. Let us know what you think.

Payments Still a Vital Part of Online Banking Success

As a one-time bill payment product manager, I've long appreciated the difficulties of making online payments live up to the hype. It was one of online banking's "dirty secrets" in the 1990s that if you wanted your bill paid quickly, you'd usually be better off whipping out your checkbook and dropping the "ink on dead trees" into the so-called snail mail (see note 1). 

Thankfully, those days are behind us. Thanks to CheckFree, Metavante, Online Resources, MasterCard RPPS, and smaller companies such as iPay Technologies, Billeo Inc., Princeton eCom (now owned by Online Resources), and Yodlee, we have reached the point where most bill payment transactions are fully electronic from consumer initiation to posting by the biller. The paper has finally been wrung from the system, at least on the remittance side. There's still some work to be done on the actual billing statement itself.  

Luckily, we have six of these payment innovators appearing at our upcoming FINOVATE 2007 conference to be held in NYC on Oct. 2, although Yodlee will be showing its online personal finance manager and Online Resources will be DEMOing its virtual collection technology. If you are interested in attending the conference, please register now, since there are only 37 seats remaining. Here's the link.

Billeo Inc.
Billeo is an outside-the-box-thinking online payments facilitator that uses the power of Web-based tools to make it easier for consumers to track and manage all their payments, both at the point-of-sale, and one-time and recurring bills. Blue-chip clients include Visa and Target among others. The Santa Clara, CA-based company won an OBR  Best of the Web in 2005 for its toolbar-based interface. The venture-backed company's innovative streak lands it on the pages of NetBanker quite frequently (see previous coverage here) and we look forward to seeing the next generation of its service at FINOVATE in three weeks.  

CheckFree
CheckFree literally created the market for online bill payment in the United States and has worked tirelessly to help convert what was once a large paper-pushing operation into a finely tuned, almost totally electronic, process. They've been the leader not only in creating a smooth back-office system, but also in smoothing out the rough edges in the payee sign-up process, in the customer interface, and in moving billers towards bill presentment. CheckFree, which closed on its acquisition of platform-provider Corillian just a few months ago, has been swept up by Fiserv in a proposed acquisition pending shareholder approval. Every year the company raises the bar for online bill payments, and I look forward to seeing what they have in store for FINOVATE attendees.

iPay Technologies
We've written about iPay Technologies in Online Banking Report a number of times, but unless you've shopped bill payment providers in the past few years, you may not be familiar with the nimble Elizabethtown, Kentucky-based firm. The privately held, 250-person bill payment specialist now handles payments for more than 1,000 banks and credit unions with a total user base just under 500,000. The company is a full-service provider offering not only bill payments, but also person-to-person payments, interbank transfers, gift-oriented payments, and even old-school telephone bill payment. If you haven't met the management team of iPay yet, you are in for a treat. Dana Bowers and her team are a delight, and I encourage everyone to talk to them during the FINOVATE breakout session.

Metavante
Metavante, wholly owned by Marshall & Ilsley, but on a path to be spun out later this year, is involved in almost every aspect of banking from risk management to loan originations and of course payments and online banking. The company's Products and Services page lists 78 items. I've had the opportunity to participate in its user conference the past three years, and it's mind-boggling to see the breadth and depth of its products displayed in one event. Its latest is a joint venture with leading UK-based mobile-provider Monitise, another FINOVATE presenter (press release here). On Oct. 2, Metavante will be demonstrating its Immediate Payments service, something that customers have long valued. It will be interesting to see how Metavante delivers on this tricky payment capability.

Note:
1. For those of you new to the bill-payment business, the reason snail mail beat online payments was that prior to the turn of the century, the majority of "online" bill payments were actually sent via snail mail, often from remote locations, that took longer to traverse the country than if the consumer had sent it themselves.

M-Com’s Customer Base

 

As mentioned in Brandon's post earlier today, New Zealand-based
M-Com has amassed an extensive client list in the Australia/New Zealand market. Whether they can make the leap to the United States is unknown, but we should find out soon, since the company is targeting some well-known U.S. banks.

 

ANZ Logo

ANZ – Mobile Phone Banking
ANZ BankAnywhere Case Study – mobile phone banking
Customer Site – ANZ Mobile banking

BNZ LogoBNZ – Mobile Credit Card Payment
BNZ PayAnywhere Case Study – M-Credit

ETSL Paymark Logo

ETSL – Mobile Payment Platform
Electronic Transaction Services Limited (ETSL / Paymark) is the transaction-processing business of New Zealand's leading banks.

ETSL/Paymark PayAnywhere Case Study – Paymark Remote
Customer Site – ETSL mobile payment engine

National Bank Logo

National Bank – Mobile Phone Banking
The National Bank – BankAnywhere Case Study – mobile phone banking
Customer Site – National Bank mobile banking

Telecom – Mobile Prepay Bill Payment
Logo TelecomTelecom customers can top up their prepay mobile phone credit, using their everyday bank account, via a simple text message instruction.

Telecom – M-Billing Case Study – Mobile Phone Recharge
Customer Site – Telecom M-TopUp

Logo WestpacWestpac – SMS Banking
Westpac – BankAnywhere Case Study – txt banking
Customer Site – Westpac SMS Banking

Bank of America Launches SafePass, but You’d Never Know From its Website

If you were in the office yesterday, you probably heard about Bank of America's announcement of SafePass, an optional out-of-band authorization technique for high-risk online banking transactions. It was all over the news, including the trades, blogs, and a few mainstream press articles. Here's the press release.

The system, common in many countries, but available only at Citibank in the United States (previous coverage here), sends users a 6-digit code via text message. The code is then entered at BofA's website to authorize larger transfers, new bill-pay merchants, new accounts for funds transfer, or to login from a new computer, not previously "registered" for online banking. VeriSign developed the technology.

The service will roll out across the BofA empire this year, with many customers having it as soon as next week. Next year, a wallet-card token "SafePass card" will be offered for customers who don't have text-messaging capabilities on their phones.

Analysis
SafePass is a solid enhancement to security, at least perceived security, since it probably won't do much to cut down on actual fraud losses. It's already pretty difficult to get through BofA's security gates and pull money out of someone's online account. The bank did the right thing in making it optional. Only the paranoiacs, road warriors, or those with unusually high transaction amounts will want to undergo the extra steps.   

So while it may be ho-hum in terms of fraud reductions, SafePass is brilliant marketing (note 1). It's a tangible and easily understood copy-point as to why one should choose BofA over the other 15,000 U.S. financial institutions. Think of the bragging rights they now have (all firsts are U.S. only):

  • First to integrate mobile messaging into the authentication process
  • First to offer optional extra security
  • First to safeguard the process of adding a new bill payment payee
  • Potentially first to offer choice of token or mobile text message for out-of-channel authorization
  • Only bank able to put "SafePass" on their websitea very good name
  • Able to say, "no one has more security options than us"
  • Able to say they are a "pioneer in security enhancements"
  • Able to they "put the customer in charge of their own extra security"
  • And so on …

Congratulations to Bank of America for once again raising the bar in online security.

Rant
While I like what the bank has done, once again I find it astonishing that even 48 hours after releasing the news in a press release here, THERE IS NOTHING ON THE BofA WEBSITE ABOUT IT. A site search for "SafePass" pretending to be from North Carolina, New York, or California results yields just a single obscure business insurance product. Bank of America's search doesn't even return the press release announcing the service!

SafePass is also not mentioned in the bank's security, online banking, or mobile banking sections. I've worked in a Fortune 50 company, so I understand all too well how hard it is to sync advertising, PR, sales, and so on at a huge company. But with 22 million active online banking users, you'd think BofA would be a leader in syncing its website to its marketing plan. 

Am I being overly critical?  It's certainly worth writing about. 

Note:

1. For more information on the synergy between security and marketing efforts, see our full report on the subject at Online Banking Report.