Skip to content

Finovate is part of the Informa Connect Division of Informa PLC

  • Informa PLC
  • About us
  • Investor relations
  • Talent

This site is operated by a business or businesses owned by Informa PLC and all copyright resides with them. Informa PLC's registered office is 5 Howick Place, London SW1P 1WG. Registered in England and Wales. Number 8860726.

More
  • Events▾
    • FinovateFall
    • FinovateAwards
    • FinovateEurope
    • FinovateSpring
  • Blog
  • Programs▾
    • Product Demos
    • Sustainable & Inclusive Demo Scholarships
    • Discounted Startup Access
    • Leadership Program
  • Best of Show
  • Videos▾
    • Demos
    • Finovate on Streamly
  • Podcast

Finovate Blog

Tracking fintech, banking & financial services innovations since 1994

Account opening

Bank Simple Innovations #3 and #4: Debit Card Mailer

By Jim Bruene Posted on August 14, 2012
Categories: Account opening, Onboarding, Simple

image Below is the second installment of our multi-part series on the innovations from Simple. The onboarding process is covered in the first two segments.

Part 1: Innovations #1 and #2: Demo mode after login

________________________________________________

#3 Novel card mailer & copy
________________________________________________

If you’ve been following the Bank Simple story, you’ve probably already seen it’s unique card mailer. It’s a simple package consisting of a cardboard CD-mailer (screenshot #1) with the Simple name on the outside.

Inside, is a clever matching cardboard piece with the card rubber-banded to a detachable bottom piece designed to be used as a very basic wallet (note 1). The cardboard says “cash” on one side and “card” on the other.

Copy is friendly and very unbank-like (see screenshot #2):

IT’S A GOOD DAY
Your new Simple Visa card is
here. Excited? We’re a bit giddy.

Activate your card and try it out.
Please let us know what you think.

It’s the best card mailer copy I’ve ever seen, but it does strike me as just a bit overly self-congratulatory. I think I’d have put a big THANK YOU at the top instead of the IT’S A GOOD DAY. But that’s a small point. Also, I love that they ask for feedback, but it would be nice to publish their email or Twitter handle to make that easier.

The back of the mailer (screenshot 3) is all business with the toll-free number, a simple URL to see the detailed terms <www.simple.com/terms>, and the name of the card issuer (Bancorp Bank).

Bottom line: Even though the Simple package appears austere, it most certainly cost much more than the generic #10 package customers are used to getting from banks and card issuers (first-class postage was $1.95 alone). But if you want users to really believe that you are different from the megabanks, you can’t just drop a plain-vanilla card mailer into their hands.

_______________________________________________________________

#4 Humanizing the card activation/PIN selection process
_______________________________________________________________

Users must dial a toll-free number to activate the card and create a PIN. While the lack of online or mobile options was a letdown, the bank did a good job with the call. As expected, the activation number was answered by a recording. But the recording from a real customer service rep, Rachel, who apparently has been actively engaging customers for more than a year.

There were no surprises in the activation process, users calling from a previously known phone number simply key in their card number and last-four digits of their social security number to activate. Then select a PIN by entering four digits twice.

The bank didn’t do any upselling, but did offer the option of connecting with a service rep for questions. I took the bank up on the offer, and briefly chatted with a service rep about the spending limits on the card. She was personable and answered the questions with no hesitation. And I liked how they answered the customer service number:

“You’ve reached customer relations at Simple. Let’s see if someone’ is available to take your call.”

Bottom line: While Simple’s card activation processed followed industry standards, you still could sense they’d put some thought into it. The little touch of being greeted by a recording from a person using her real name, helps build rapport during the opening days of the relationship.

—————————————–

#1: Simple debit card mailer — envelope front (13 Aug 2012)
Note: DVD shown for scale only, not part of package.

image

#2: Card mailer front

image

#3: Card mailer back

image

Note:
1. The “rubber-band wallet” may be lost on some. My wife didn’t get that one at all. But she still thought it was a cool way to hold the card to the mailer without using  adhesive which must be scraped off.

Share this:

Send Post Twitter LinkedIn Facebook

Bank Simple Innovations #1 & #2: Demo Mode After Login

By Jim Bruene Posted on July 31, 2012
Categories: Account opening, Onboarding, Simple

image I started my <bank> Simple relationship yesterday by responding to an email invite supplied by a reader (note 1). As expected, the application and initial on-boarding experience is tremendous. I’ve already catalogued a few dozen noteworthy innovations. But instead of writing an enormous blog entry, I will deliver them in smaller doses.
________________________________________________

#1 Allowing account login right away
________________________________________________

One area ripe for improvement at many FIs is the online on-boarding process. Typically, after applying for an account, new customers must wait a week or more to get account info and cards in the mail before they can even login to their account.

At Simple, once the new account application is verified and approved (this took less than 30 minutes for mine), users are invited to set up their account online and to download the mobile app.

After completing that process, users can log into their account and look over the features. Because new accounts are devoid of data, the startup offers a demo mode that allows new users to start learning about the account by using its features with fictional transaction data (see #2 below).

Bank Simple invites new customer to login and "have fun"

__________________________________________________

#2 Interactive demo mode
__________________________________________________

Many banks have an online banking demo available. Usually, it is limited to a static guided tour. But the best ones are also interactive, allowing users to play with the features as if they were using their own account.

Simple has taken the latter approach with an interactive demo. But instead of burying it somewhere on the public website, the startup has built a demo mode option right into its online banking interface. Users simply choose the demo option in the intro box on the main page, and the site opens up full of sample data that users can play with.

This is especially useful for new users who have no real data to manipulate.

Once in demo mode, users can turn it off using the toggle switch in the upper left or by clicking the X next to where demo mode was launched.

———————————–

Before: Demo mode is activated with this button

Entering demo mode at Bank Simple
After: Demo mode is shut off with toggle

Bank Simple demo mode

——————————————–

Notes:
1. Thanks to Michael Bagniewski, VP & Director of Information Technology at PNA Bank, for sharing his extra invite (he inadvertently put himself on Simple’s waitlist with two email addresses). Apparently, Simple invites are transferrable, though none are listed on eBay yet.
2. We looked at the new crop of Truly Virtual Banks (including Simple) in our Oct 2011 Online Banking Report (subscription).

Share this:

Send Post Twitter LinkedIn Facebook

First Look: The Application & Onboarding Process for PayPal Here

By Jim Bruene Posted on June 28, 2012
Categories: Account opening, Alt Payments, Mobile Payments, PayPal

image I put my name on the list for PayPal Here (its response to Square) when it was announced in the spring. Yesterday, I received my invitation to “apply” for the service.

I was a little surprised that I still had to apply given that I’ve had this PayPal account since 1999, and have run many thousands of dollars through it, both as a buyer and a merchant. But I understand the enormous risks in payment acceptance, so I will happily oblige some hassle. 

Interestingly, the process must be done via the mobile PayPal Here app. You cannot simply complete the application via PayPal’s normal online system. Again, this is slightly inconvenient for me, but it’s good to see PayPal enabling the mobile app for signup. This may be the first financial product from a major U.S. company that has a mobile-only app process.

The mobile signup process is a little confusing. First, you must download the separate PayPal Here app (it in not integrated with the regular PayPal app). Then when launched, if you press “register” on the opening screen (screenshot below), instead of being allowed to register, you are asked to put yourself on the PayPal Here waitlist

I thought I’d hit a dead end, so I went back to the invitation email (below). What you must do instead is login to the app with your PayPal credentials (note 1). Once in, users go through a quick account verification, then a merchants services mini-application, and ID check against credit bureau data.

At the end of the process, a reader is mailed to your business address and an optional debit card is mailed to your primary address on file. But you are immediately allowed to begin accepting payments through by scanning a card with the mobile camera or keying it in. That’s impressive.

The next day, I received an email with a tracking number for the reader (screenshot below).

Bottom line: The process seemed a little convoluted for an existing customer. But, in all it took 4 to 5 minutes and required no supporting info and I was able to accept a credit card immediately. Had I not had trouble logging in, I could have completed it in closer under 3 minutes. Overall, I score it a B+.   

—————————————-

Email to apply for PayPal Here (26 June 2012)

PayPal here email invitation

 

PayPal Here login screen
Note: Invited users must login, NOT try to register (which won’t work)

PayPal here login screen mobile

Pre-populated account                 Card reader
verification
                                              confirmation screen

PayPal here application mobile    PayPal Here card reader confirmation

Confirmation email the next day (28 June 2012)

image

————————–

Note:
1. The email said to login with my PayPal email address and password. I got an odd error message doing that, saying to “append my code to the password.” I think this is because I have second factor authentication turned on for my PayPal account. But I could not see any way to get a code sent to me through the PayPal Here app, so I was stuck. I then tried logging in with my PayPal mobile credentials, and that worked fine. It seems like there might be a bug here. 

Share this:

Send Post Twitter LinkedIn Facebook

Out of the Inbox: Repossessed Vehicle Auction Announcement

By Jim Bruene Posted on December 29, 2011
Categories: Account opening, Email Samples, Loans & Credit

image As a semi-reformed eBay addict, anything with auction in the title still grabs my attention. And of the thousands of emails I get from banks every year, I believe this one from Ohio Valley Bank is the first ever for a vehicle auction. 

If you are selling off repos and REOs, you should let your customers get on a mail list announcing them. You could even turn it into a membership benefit, giving customers first crack at the deals and/or providing preferential financing.

Ohio Valley offers preapproved auction financing for its repo sales. A good move, although its landing page and online app could use a facelift (see second and third screenshots).

—————————

Ohio Valley Bank email announcing vehicle auction (link; received 29 Dec 2011; 6:35 AM Pacific)
Note: I am not a customer of the bank, but anyone can sign up for its emails.

Email from Ohio Valley Bank announcing its next vehicle auction

Landing page for auction financing (link)

Landing page for auction financing

One-page online loan app (click to enlarge; link)

image 

———————————-

Note: Ohio Valley Bank has a prominent link on its homepage to its holiday hours, a nice touch (see picture upper right).

Share this:

Send Post Twitter LinkedIn Facebook

The Day Before BTD, More "Switch" Efforts

By Jim Bruene Posted on November 4, 2011
Categories: Account opening, Advertising & Promotion, Verity CU

image In banking, we haven’t had as much hype over a single day since Y2K. But with every major bank back-pedaling on debit card fees, the power of tomorrow’s Bank Transfer Day has  diminished somewhat. Yet, it still should be a good week for smaller players to grab market share.

The Deposit Accounts blog had a run down of some special offers in effect tomorrow, including the “gloves off” homepage promo from Seattle’s Verity Credit Union (click inset to enlarge; note 1).

And here are a few more switch pages. Last week, I highlighted Freestar Bank’s effort. Here are four more (screenshots/links below):

  • Community 1st CU
  • 1st Advantage CU
  • First Bank and Trust
  • Bank of Tennessee, which has the most interesting landing page by a long-shot (see last three screenshots)

All but the first are are powered by Deluxe’s SwitchAgent (note 2).

——————————

Community 1st Credit Union homepage (link; 31 Oct 2011)

Community 1st Credit Union

1st Advantage FCU homepage (link)

SwitchAgent at Homepage: 1st Advantage FCU

First Bank and Trust homepage (link)
Note: You cannot click through this ad. The call to action is “visit your banker”

Homepage: First Bank and Trust

Bank of Tennessee homepage (link)

image

Bank of Tennessee landing page, part 1 (link)

Bank of Tennessee switch Landing page, part 1 (link)

Landing page part 2

Landing page part 2

Landing page part 3

Landing page part 3

————————————-

Notes:
1. While you are at Verity click over to its Verity Mom social media effort (powered by Currency Marketing) and see the amazing turnout they had for their second annual spokester contest, 69 one-minute videos were submitted.
2. The reason why I’m showing so many Deluxe examples is because I used “SwitchAgent” in my search and found interesting examples. They have 14 clients using the new service, which we first heard about at BAI Retail Delivery a few weeks ago.
3. We write about these issues and much more in our subscription service, Online Banking Report.

Share this:

Send Post Twitter LinkedIn Facebook

Switching Checking Accounts in the Online Banking Era

By Jim Bruene Posted on October 27, 2011
Categories: Account opening, Account Switching

image There is a bit of a media frenzy going on right now about the idea of consumers cutting the cord to their bank (or DVD rental company) due to new fees and/or price increases. There are even t-shirts (see inset), a sure sign things are getting a bit crazy.

Within the industry, there’s been much debate over whether consumers will actually act upon their frustration and move accounts to “main street” banks and credit unions. 

Certainly some will (see update). One of our young employees just did, thanks to the debit card fee. You probably know someone that has too. And most likely, it’s someone with relatively simple finances. Because those of us with more complicated situations brought on by marriage, children, home buying, car buying, credit card usage, business ownership and so on, face a daunting lists of tasks to move our accounts (see below). 

While millions will change banks to lower checking costs, most will stay put because they are satisfied overall or they simply want to avoid spending a good part of a Saturday going through the tedious switching process. Tools designed to ease the pain, such as Deluxe’s new SwitchAgent, can help (see screenshots from FreeStar Bank below). But it’s still a painful process (just look at that last worksheet), even if you have a friendly helper on the phone providing moral support and making calls on your behalf.

This doesn’t mean you can ignore customer needs, or tack on new fees willy nilly. Because eventually you are going to need new customers, regardless of how lethargic your existing ones are.

________________________________________________________________________

Switching a checking account in 1987
________________________________________________________________________

In the old days (like back when I had simple finances), all you had to do to switch your checking account was:

  • Go to the branch of your new financial institution and open a new checking account
  • Decide what style checks to order
  • Figure out how many outstanding paper checks you’ve written on your old account and  make sure you left enough money in the old account to cover them

_________________________________________________________________________

Switching a checking account in 2011
_________________________________________________________________________

In addition to the above (you might be able to save the trip to the branch if full online account opening is offered), today’s wired consumer must also do the following:

  • Contact the merchants, insurance companies and financial institutions who use preauthorized debit to grab money from you each month, and switch them to the new checking account (and hope they make the change in the time period they promised)
  • Contact your HR department to switch payroll direct deposit to the new account
  • If you have overdraft lines of credit, apply for new ones at the new financial institution
  • In online banking, cancel all the pending payments
  • In online banking, write down biller and payee contact info and capture any history you want to record
  • In online banking, download/print transactional history or record any historical info you need to keep; including check images if necessary
  • If you use e-statements, download and save all prior statements
  • Register for online banking at the new financial institution and reset your preferences and security settings
  • Register for mobile banking at the new financial institution
  • Reestablish email and mobile alerts at the new financial institution
  • Find convenient and free ATMs that support your new financial institution
  • If you have a car loan or mortgage at the old financial institution that offered a discounted rate for automatic payments from their checking account, you may want to keep the old account open with enough cash in it each month, until those loans are paid off

And repeat the whole process if you also have a business checking account you want to move at the same time.

————————–

Update (28 Oct): Raddon published an article today showing no change in the number of consumers saying they closed an account (during the past 12 months) in 2010/2011 compared to 2005/2006. The closure rate in both periods was 9%. 

————————-

Freestar Bank is running a large switching ad on its homepage (one of five in rotation)

image

SwitchAgent landing page (link)
Note: Switching service is powered by Deluxe’s new SwitchAgent program that handles the heavy lifting for a reported $60 per switch

image

Downloadable form to be filled out before talking to the SwitchAgent (link)

image 

Note:
1. Fee-H8R graphic tees available from CUNA here.
2. We write about these issues and much more in our subscription service, Online Banking Report.

Share this:

Send Post Twitter LinkedIn Facebook

Bank of America Sponsoring Free Wi-Fi for Smartphones on Alaska Airlines Flights

By Jim Bruene Posted on August 9, 2011
Categories: Account opening, Advertising & Promotion, Bank of America, Credit/Debit Cards, Mobile Banking

imageA few days ago I was on a Chicago-Seattle flight on Alaska Airlines and was surprised to hear an overhead announcement about Bank of America sponsoring free wi-fi on the flight. But it came with a catch, the free access applied only to smartphones (notes 1, 2).

While I’m a big user of airborne wi-fi on my laptop, there isn’t much I want to do on a smartphone connection at 35,000 feet. But my curiosity got the best of me, so I gave it a shot and found the free connection was delivered as promised. I had simply to type in my email address, agree to the terms and conditions, and hit the big blue button (see first screenshot).

It didn’t take me long to figure out why BofA was being so generous. The second page of the sign-on process included a full-page ad for the bank’s Alaska Airlines affinity card (see second screenshot).

My take: Sponsored wi-fi is an effective way to reach the lucrative smartphone-carrying market. But the credit card application user experience was flawed. The bank dumps the whole app and disclosures onto a single mobile webpage, which required scrolling down about eight screens’ worth of info (see screenshots 3, 4, and 5). And the fonts were way too small to engage most users.

If BofA were to build a proper mobile-optimized credit card application form, they’d likely increase app volume two- to three-fold. In the meantime, the bank should add an option for the user to request a full-sized app to be completed later on their laptop. 
———————————————-

1. First screen of free wi-fi promotion on Alaska Airlines (7 Aug. 2011)

1. First screen of free wi-fi promotion on Alaska Airlines

2. BofA credit card solicitation on page 2 of the login process

2. BofA credit card solicitation on page 2 of the login process

3, 4, 5: The rest of the mobile application (click to enlarge)
Note: This shows only the beginning of the disclosures; the full text ran several more screens down the page.

image  image  image

————————————

Notes:
1. I didn’t test it, but I assume it would have been free on the iPad as well.
2. I believe they said the offer would continue through the month of August.

Share this:

Send Post Twitter LinkedIn Facebook

Why I Got My Car Loan Through the Dealer Instead of My Online Bank

By Jim Bruene Posted on June 29, 2011
Categories: Account opening, Loans & Credit, Rants, Service

(Rant alert: If you are tired of analyst/blogger whining over perceived personal service affronts, it would be best to hit delete now.)

image I don’t think there is an actual name for this, but I am car-dealer phobic. Seriously. On more than one occasion, I’ve driven all the way to the dealer. Parked my car. And then driven away as soon as I saw the sales guy (they have all been guys) ambling over. It’s weird.

But I found eBay Motors about 10 years ago and have been overall very happy with the three vehicles I’ve bought there. So that would be the end of the story, if I wasn’t married.

My otherwise wonderful wife greatly prefers vehicles with that new-car smell, not the ones that arrive needing an $1800 catalytic converter to pass the emissions test (my most recent eBay “deal”). And I can’t really complain, because she’s perfectly willing to drive the thing for a decade or more.  

Good online application UX
So she ordered a new car and put me in charge of paying for it (does that sound familiar to anyone?). Being an online-only shopper, I went to my favorite car loan specialist (note 1) and completed their online app. The app itself was flawless and took only a few minutes.

While I was disappointed that I wasn’t approved in real-time, I received an email a few minutes later congratulating me on my loan approval. But there was a catch. In order to “to protect my privacy, (the bank) needed to verify some information.” So would I please call. That was 2 weeks ago.

Terrible income verification UX
So I called the next day. What I found didn’t totally surprise me. Despite being a customer of this financial institution (with an open credit line higher than the price of the car), and the fact that I’ve borrowed and paid back two car loans with them previously, and that I requested a 3-year loan which minimizes their collateral risk, and that I have good credit, the bank wanted to verify my income. And because I’m a business owner (not salaried), they needed 3 months of bank statements.

So I dug out the old statements, scanned them (note 2), and emailed them to the bank. There was no confirmation they were received, nor did the online loan-status indicator change (it simply said “approved”). I did that 12 days ago.

Then I waited for a week and heard nothing. So I called back and was told they hadn’t looked at the docs yet, but that they would expedite them. That was six days ago.

The next day, I received an email from the bank asking me to call again. You know that’s not good news. Here’s how that call went:

  • Bank: We cannot verify your income because it shows as “Internet transfers” on your bank statement.
    Me: But my business banking account is at the same bank as my personal one, so when I get paid, it’s called a “transfer” because it is one.  
    Bank: Sorry, we only consider it income if the bank statement says “deposit.”  
  • Me: OK, I can understand that, how about I send you my 2010 tax return?
    Bank: Sorry, we don’t accept tax returns for income verification.
  • Me: OK, how about if I send you the last 3 months of my business bank statements, then you can see the transfers leaving that account and landing in my personal account. 
    Bank: Sorry, we can’t accept biz-bank statements because we don’t make commercial loans.
  • Me: Can we move this application to an exception processing area for manager review?
    Bank: Sorry, we don’t do that.
  • Me: Is there any way you can think of that I could verify my income? 
    Bank: Do you have a spouse with W-2 income?
    Me: No
    Bank: Then unfortunately, I don’t see any way that we can verify your income. Sorry.
  • Me: Then what I hear you saying is that there is no way for me to get the loan you approved me for?
    Bank: Sorry, but that’s the case.

With that we ended the conversation. Rather abruptly if I recall. (I will say, she was actually very nice throughout the whole call, so partial credit for that.)

After I’d cooled down a bit, I decided to call back and try my luck with another rep. Sure enough, after I explained the situation and offered to send the corresponding biz-bank statements to verify the transfers, he said, “That makes sense, let me check with my manager.” Within a minute or two he came back on and said that my solution should work and to please send the business banking statements. Which I did, right away. And again no confirmation that they were received. That was 4 days ago.

After hearing nothing for two more days (this is supposedly being “expedited”), I called back and was told it was under review and there was nothing they could do to speed it up. That was 2 days ago. I haven’t heard anything since.

The car dealer to the rescue
Because I had to pay for the car in full this week or forfeit the deposit, I gave up on my online bank and called the dealer. At their instruction, I completed their short online form, was approved by their indirect lender (thank you U.S. Bank!), and went in and signed the papers. Start-to-finish in just a few hours. There was no income verification. And I even got a better rate.

Lessons for Netbankers: Experiences like this is what gives online lending a bad name. This is the third time in a row I’ve had a really poor experience with an online loan app. I understand that my self-employment, even after 16 years, makes underwriting more difficult in these cautious times. But you need to have a process in place where denied applicants can request a quick review of their application, detailing the mitigating factors.

Simply leaving prospective customers hanging is not good business.   

—————————————-

Notes:
1. My policy is to not to disclose the name of the financial institution if it’s about an issue or problem with my personal situation. But I will email you the name as long as you identify yourself and agree not to publicly post it (send to [email protected]).  
2. Unfortunately, I couldn’t simply download estatements since my bank does not offer them, unless you give up your paper statement.
3. For more on online account opening, see Online Banking Report: Improving Online Account Opening ROI (published June 2009). 

Share this:

Send Post Twitter LinkedIn Facebook

Andera Launches Fortifi, Networking 500 Clients Together to Thwart Online Accounting Opening Fraud

By Jim Bruene Posted on June 13, 2011
Categories: Account opening, Andera, Security

image I’ve opened about 40 to 50 accounts online in the past decade and rarely has the experience been satisfactory (see note 1). The best experience yet was opening a PNC Virtual Wallet early last year. And I didn’t know until after I’d published the blog entry, that the app was powered by Andera (note 2).

So I pay attention when the Rhode Island-based tech company introduces a new feature. The company already had fraud algorithms that stopped most attempts. But there is no such thing as perfect security. So to make it even more robust, Andera is adding real-time monitoring of the application flow across its entire 500-client network to do an even better job of catching criminals.

imageUnder the new Fortifi system, criminals simultaneously applying at multiple financial institutions (on the Andera platform) are indentified in real-time and stopped. Andrea believes the new system will reduce fraud to less than 5 out of every 1,000 applications approved compared to 20 to 30 frauds per 1,000 approved previously.

Even for a smaller institution doing 100 online apps a month, that’s one or two fewer frauds to chase down each month, a material cost savings and a reduction in the management burden fraud entails at smaller organizations. It also helps boost internal trust of the online channel, perhaps the biggest benefit of all.

———————————————

Andera homepage features a pensive pig, apparently wary of new account fraud

image

Notes:
1. See Online Banking Report: Improving Online Account Opening ROI (published June 2009; paywall).    
2. The post was changed to include Andera a short time later.

Share this:

Send Post Twitter LinkedIn Facebook

Chase Bank’s Checking Account Recommender is Flawed

By Jim Bruene Posted on March 29, 2011
Categories: Account opening, Chase Bank, Deposits, Checking, Savings, CDs, Website Usability & Design

image Yesterday, I visited Chase Bank’s checking account sales page (screenshot 1 below). Overall, I was impressed. The page is attractive and the bank lays out the options well. I especially liked the icons across the page emphasizing the free benefits applicable to all account types: online/mobile banking, alerts, ATMs and the debit card. Finally, it’s easy to figure out how to apply for an account online.

However, the bank’s “help me choose” function is flawed (though wisely buried at the bottom of the page, so it may be lightly used). It starts out fine by asking two simple questions:

  • What is your estimated deposit balance you’ll keep at Chase?
  • Are you interested in checking account benefits for students age 13-24? (Yes/No)

But things quickly go off the rails.

Flaw #1: Bad form design

Since I have two kids in the student bracket, I naturally chose “yes” to the second question (see second screenshot). I wasn’t looking for a student account, but sure, I’m interested. And I thought it was pretty smart of Chase to try to sell me on a kid’s account from the get-go.

However, the bank assumed that was all I cared about and pushed me towards student bank accounts even though I’d said I was keeping $15,000+ on deposit (see third screenshot).

So I went back to that page to change the student selection and discovered that once your selection is made, it cannot be changed. Even when you click the “clear” button, the radio button stays set to “Yes.” You have to choose “cancel,” which sends you all the way back to the previous page, and then start over from scratch. By that time, many (most?) customers will have moved on. 

Flaw #2: Not enough info gathered to make meaningful recommendations

While I applaud the simplicity of the wizard, the bank can’t really make a solid recommendation knowing only my anticipated deposit balance. There has to be some understanding of how the customer values the features of the deluxe checking account options such as no-fee non-Chase ATM usage, free OD transfers, free companion checking accounts, free safety-deposit box (see recommendations, screenshots 4 and 5).

Flaw #3: Doesn’t identify existing customers 

And speaking of missing info, the bank is neglecting a huge part of the equation, whether I’m an existing customer or not. In fact, I do have a business account there and just a few days ago an in-branch account rep had pitched a free companion personal checking account to me. But the checking account wizard doesn’t ask if I’m an existing customer (and the bank apparently is not using cookies to hone in on that either).

Bottom line: Chase does a good job engaging checking account prospects, but it’s missing an opportunity to help them choose the right account.

——————————————————————

Chase Bank’s main checking account page (28 March 2011)

Chase Bank's main checking account page (28 March 2011)

The help-me-choose wizard

The help-me-choose a checking account wizard at Chase Bank

Results page when checking the student box on the wizard

Results page when checking the student box on the wizard Chase Bank

Results page if student not checked (and balance equals $15k+)

Chase Results page if student not checked (and balance equals $15k)

Results page if student not checked (and balance is less than $15k)

Results page if student not checked (and balance is less than $15k)  

———————————————-

Note: For more on online account opening, see our Online Banking Report: Online Account Opening (June 2009).

Share this:

Send Post Twitter LinkedIn Facebook

Wells Fargo is Not Accepting Credit Card Applications Online from Non-Customers

By Jim Bruene Posted on December 2, 2010
Categories: Account opening, Credit/Debit Cards, Wells Fargo

image You know there are still improvements to be made in the channel when the fourth largest bank in the country doesn’t accept online credit card applications from non-customers. (Update, 3 Dec.: Apparently, this is a long-standing Wells Fargo policy, not a reaction to the recent credit market; see second comment.)

Consumers applying for a credit card at the Wells Fargo website are first asked if they are current Wells or Wachovia customers (see first screenshot). If the answer is “no,” then they are out of luck. The bank won’t allow an application online (note 1). They won’t even take a secured card application.

And the bank expends little effort trying to convert these would-be applicants into deposit customers. There is no link to the online checking account app, just a small text link to the bank’s location page where customers are encouraged to look for a branch to try their luck at the new-accounts desk. 

Analysis: I understand that it’s costly to process applications when only a small portion are approved. And customer ill-will generated by credit declines is also bad for the brand (something that I’ve recently had first-hand experience with).

But surely there are better alternatives than simply slamming the door on non-customers. For example, Capital One and Discover allow applicants to find out if they are on a “preapproved” list before applying (previous post). That, plus educational messages, could help slow the flood of unqualified applicants.  

Wells Fargo’s credit card application screens applicants by asking if they are current customers (link; 2 Dec. 2010 from Seattle ISP, Firefox 3.6.12)

Wells Fargo's credit card application asks one question in step 1 (

Non-customers are uninvited to apply 
Note: Highlights are ours

Wells Fargo Response to non-customers  

—————

Note:
1. A friend in Texas told me about this earlier this week and sent me a screenshot to prove it. I thought it might be a regional thing, but I got the same message when I tried to apply from my Washington IP address. And I am a Wells Fargo customer, so they must not be consulting cookies when delivering this message.

Share this:

Send Post Twitter LinkedIn Facebook

Capital One’s Online Prequalification System Rocks

By Jim Bruene Posted on November 17, 2010
Categories: Account opening, Advertising & Promotion, Capital One, Credit/Debit Cards

image If you’ve read Netbanker a bit, you know I can get pretty excited at just about any new and shiny bit of fintech. So if you went only by my blog posts, it might be hard to differentiate between a cool new feature and a major strategic disruption. 

Well, take note, this is one of the big ones if Capital One can deliver on the promise. And that is a very important caveat. The card giant better be able to fulfill cards to the vast majority of those it prequalifies online or it will have legions of disgruntled applicants.

What the company has done is place a pre-qualification form between its online ads (see banner running on TechCrunch below) and the full application. The form asks for name, mail address, and last four digits of the Social Security Number, plus two multiple-choice questions about desired features and credit self-evaluation. 

The whole process can be completed in as little as 35 seconds (in my test it took 24 seconds to fill in the blanks; 8 seconds for the results to be displayed).

Importance: Credit-savvy consumers, about the only ones who’ll be approved these days, know that every credit application negatively impacts their credit score, at least temporarily. Therefore, many are hesitant to complete an online app if they think there’s a chance they won’t be approved. Being able to test your creditworthiness (note 1) without a credit bureau hit is a powerful incentive to move consumers into the sales process.

The other advantage of this system is that even if you don’t complete the full application after the pre-qual, Capital One has captured your name, address, and a positive match with your SSN. So they can hit you with followups in the near future. However, I am surprised the company doesn’t ask for your email address. It must have dampened response in testing. 

Capital One banner ad across TechCrunch (17 Nov. 2010)

image

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Landing page emphasizing the lack of risk to your credit score (link)Capital One Landing page emphasizes lack of risk to your credit score

Pre-qualification form

Capital One prequalification form

Results page with a recommended card and two alternatives
Note: I indicated a preference for travel rewards in the pre-qualification form.

Capital One prequalification results page

Online application
Note: Users must start over as none of the pre-qualification form info is transferred over

image

Notes:
1. At the end of the pre-qualification process, the company only says you are “pre-qualified.” There is no guarantee you’ll get the card or credit limit you want.
2. For more on online lending, consult our previous OBR reports:
– Online Lending v5.0 (part 1) (Nov. 2005)
– Online Lending v5 (part 2) (Jan. 2006) 

Share this:

Send Post Twitter LinkedIn Facebook

Posts navigation

  • ← Previous
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • Next →

Search

FinovateFall-blog

FinovateFall

FinovateAwards

FinovateAwards

FinovateEurope 2026

FinovateEurope

FinovateSpring 2026

FinovateSpring

Subscribe by Email

Want us to cover your news?

Contact [email protected]

Follow us on Twitter

Twitter Icon
Followers

Tags

#WomeninFinTech Alumni profile Analyst All Stars Atos Banking Credit Sesame Daily News Debt Goal Diversity DSwiss eMagazine Email Emerging technology Finovate Digital Week Finovate eMagazine FinovateEurope 2022 FinovateFall FinovateFall 2021 Finovate Live Finovate Marketing FinovateSpring 2022 FinovateSpring Takeover Finovate Webinar Identity Verification Innovation InterSystems Julie's Column Lending MSPs News payments PFM Plaid Ripple Labs SME lending Sponsored StreetShares Tradier Videos Wealth Management Platform Webinar Whitepaper Women in Fintech Xignite Yodlee

RSS Latest Finovate blog posts

  • Streamly Snapshot: Navigating Embedded Banking—Challenges and Breakthroughs
  • Thought Machine Inks Partnership with DXC Technology
  • Carrington Labs Partners with Taktile to Enhance Credit Risk Strategies for Lenders

About

Who We Are Sponsor Apply to Demo
RSS Feed Twitter LinkedIn

Events

FinovateEurope FinovateSpring FinovateFall FinovateAwards

Videos

Demo Videos

Podcast

Podcast Archives

  • Home
  • Cookies
  • Privacy
  • Terms

 

Copyright © 2007-2024 Finovate. All rights reserved.

Demo your latest fintech product or innovation in front of 1000+ decision makers including 600+ from banks and investors.

Apply Now!