Unitus Community Credit Union Charging $2 Monthly for Geezeo-Powered Online Financial Management (PFM)
In what I believe is a first in the United States, a financial institution has begun charging a small fee for online personal financial management (PFM) services.
Portland, OR-based Unitus Community Credit Union, with 68,000 members and $800 million in assets, launched its new Geezeo-powered PFM Total Finance in late 2010. Members pay $2 per month for the service following a 30-day free trial.
According to Laurie Kresl, VP planning & biz development at Unitus, the CU has 661 members signed up for the service as of this week, or about 1% of its member base, which is a solid start considering the monthly fee is not mentioned on the public website, but is disclosed as members sign up for the service (note 1).
Quick take: While online/mobile access will remain relatively fee-free, we’ll begin to see more fees for optional value-added services such as advanced financial management. Congratulations to Unitus for taking the lead on this one.
Unitus CU homepage features its new PFM offering (6 Jan. 2011)
PFM landing page (link)
Note:
1. To sign up, customers first log in to online banking. The CU says it plans to add fine print to the landing page (above), disclosing the monthly fee.
Wells Fargo Remodels its Mobile Website, WF.com
I just realized that I haven’t posted anything about non-app-based mobile websites (aka WAP) since the pre-iPhone days of early 2007, when I tried unsuccessfully to log in to ING Direct’s mobile site through my trusty Samsung Blackjack.
Mobile banking has come a long way since then, primarily through native apps, now supported by more than 1,000 financial institutions in the U.S. alone. But a mobile-optimized website is still an important part of your overall mobile mix. Not everyone has a smartphone and not every smartphone user will download your app.
And some observers believe that the mobile Web, enhanced with HTML 5 and whatever comes next, will eventually run all the apps out of business. With 300,000 apps for the iPhone already created, I think that’s unlikely, but possible.
But whatever the future holds, today you need a good mobile-optimized website. And Wells Fargo, for one, hasn’t forgotten about it. Today they sent an email to customers announcing a remodeled mobile site at WF.com, its mobile URL (see screenshot below).
After logging in at the WF.com site, users are greeted with a menu button that opens up a new window of choices (note arrow in screenshot). It’s a nice way to navigate and makes the mobile website feel more like an app. The email also says there is more info on the page to minimize clicking, an important change. I still prefer the native app (note 1), but this is a nice improvement.
Wells Fargo email to customers announcing its redesigned mobile banking site, WF.com (5 Jan. 2011; landing page)
Note: The “Menu” button, when pressed, opens or closes the navigation choices (shown in open mode below)
————–
Note:
1. Ironically, the native app doesn’t seem to be working on my iPhone 4 at the moment (update 6 Jan., it’s working now). Another reason you want to have a good mobile website alternative.
New Year’s Resolutions for Online and Mobile Banking
Last year, one of my personal new year’s resolutions was published in the New York Times Bucks blog. That provided extra motivation to make it happen, though ultimately I still fell short in my goal to cancel one unused recurring service each month.
But I like the motivational benefits of making goals public, so in that vein I’m publishing my first annual list of new year’s resolutions for the online/mobile banking industry (roughly in priority order):
1. Make online/mobile banking a profit center: Cross subsidies work in many industries, e.g., giving away the razor to sell the blade. But with Congress determined to regulate the price of blades, it’s time to start pricing the razor for the value it delivers. Online/mobile banking provides enormous benefits for consumers and even more for businesses. It’s time to charge for it, at least for premium services.
2. Mobilize: Retail banks did a great job going mobile in 2010. And online-balance queries and transaction lookup are the all-important table stakes going forward. But that’s not the end of the project. Mobile is more important to your future than online, so work hard on your version 2.0 mobile service launching this year or next.
3. Make it family friendly: Kids these days have grown up online and will do all their financial work via online/mobile services. Financial services companies should take a page from the telecom industry and start providing youth banking services via family bundles controlled by the parents.
4. Socialize: I’m in the camp that there is no such thing as a bad financial institution blog, Facebook page, or tweet. Boring? Yes. Lame? Sure. But, any reasonable effort is better than none. In 1996, there were a lot of bad Web pages. But was it better to get a page posted and learn from it or spend years developing a great “Web strategy” before doing anything? Early adopters are usually willing to cut you some slack on your first “beta version.” Just the fact that you are willing to get your feet wet automatically puts you above the competition.
5. Make it into a game: Over the holidays, I read a great article in Fast Company about how everything we do can, and probably will, be made into a game. And banking has a head start on other businesses looking to make a game out of everyday commerce. Frequent flyer points for credit card purchases started this movement more than 20 years ago. Now, everything a customer does financially can be rewarded with loyalty points all tracked through pervasive online/mobile connectivity.
I could go on, but then it would be harder to achieve my new year’s resolution of publishing an Online Banking Report on each of these topics.
Early-Bird Ticket Deadline for FinovateEurope Extended — Register by January 7 to Save £100!
Due to a number of requests for an extension of early-bird pricing on tickets to FinovateEurope because of the holidays, we’ve extended the early-registration discount deadline to this Friday January 7th.
The conference (February 1 in London) is going to be great with three dozen innovative fintech companies scheduled to demo their latest Fintech innovations on stage. By registering, you’ll join hundreds of executives from companies such as:
|
|
Buying your ticket
before the end of this week will get you the £100 early-registration
discount and it will also reserve your seat at the conference. We’ve
sold out at the last two Finovate events and ticket sales are strong for
this show as well. We hope to see you in London!
FinovateEurope 2011 is sponsored by: BlueRock Consulting, Microsoft, Santander, Sapient & The Bancorp
FinovateEurope 2011 is partners with: 154 Consulting, BankerStuff, BankInnovation.net, Banking Automation Bulletin, CardWeb, Filene, Finance on Windows, The Financial Services Innovation Centre, PYMNTS.com & theStartup.eu.
Early-Bird Ticket Deadline for FinovateEurope Extended — Register by Friday January 7 to Save £100!
Due to a number of requests for an extension of early-bird pricing on tickets to FinovateEurope because of the holidays, we’ve extended the early-registration discount deadline to this Friday January 7th.
The conference (February 1 in London) is going to be great with three dozen innovative fintech companies scheduled to demo their latest Fintech innovations on stage. By registering, you’ll join hundreds of executives from companies such as:
|
|
Buying your ticket
before the end of this week will get you the £100 early-registration
discount and it will also reserve your seat at the conference. We’ve
sold out at the last two Finovate events and ticket sales are strong for
this show as well. We hope to see you in London!
FinovateEurope 2011 is sponsored by: BlueRock Consulting, Microsoft, Santander, Sapient & The Bancorp
FinovateEurope 2011 is partners with: 154 Consulting, BankerStuff, BankInnovation.net, Banking Automation Bulletin, CardWeb, Filene, Finance on Windows, The Financial Services Innovation Centre, PYMNTS.com & theStartup.eu.
Alumni News — Week of December 29, 2010
Alumni News — Weeks of December 13 and 20, 2010
To see Finovate news updates in real-time, follow our feed on Twitter.
Backbase explores mobile banking in its fall webinar series. http://bit.ly/finovate1293
BlazeMobile creates smart payments sticker.http://bit.ly/finovate12133
BrightScope releases top 30 retirement plans. http://bit.ly/finovate12143
Capital Access special report on “Black Friday” and small business sales data. http://bit.ly/finovate1282
SunTrust has added the “Transfer Now” product suite from CashEdge including person-to-person and me-to-me transfers. http://bit.ly/finovate12165
ClairMail and Cardlytics partner to provide transaction marketing opportunities. http://bit.ly/finovate1281
Expensify is hiring for multiple positions. – The company is currently looking for Web developers and computer engineers at several levels. http://bit.ly/finovate1216
FIS launches innovative new mobile banking product. — Users can establish mobile account management with their debit card, no online banking signup needed. http://bit.ly/finovate1291
Geezeo selected by University Federal Credit Union as PFM provider. http://bit.ly/finovate12151
GoalMine hosting cash contest via Facebook to spread the word. http://bit.ly/finovate1292
Kapitall closes series A funding round. — The company did not release funding amounts or sources. http://bit.ly/finovate12163
Congratulations to Mint founder, Aaron Patzer, winner of a TechFellow Award for General Management. http://tcrn.ch/finovate1296
Mozo powering new “Compare, Ditch and Switch” campaign. — The services allows Australians to shop around for better banking services. http://bit.ly/finovate1283
Just in time for the Holidays, PopMoney gift cards at www.giftcardmall.com.
SmartyPig launches cash rewards card with only a one-time activation fee of $4.95. http://bit.ly/finovate12134
Victrio receives $5 million investment for voice-printing technology. http://bit.ly/finovate12141
Holiday Marketing at the Top 20 U.S. Banks
For five of the seven Decembers I’ve spent blogging, I’ve perused the holiday Web-based marketing efforts of the 20 largest U.S. banks. This year, 10 jumped on the holiday bandwagon, an increase of 67% over the six last year. In 2004, only 4 of the 20 were running holiday promotions (on Dec. 21).
Previous posts: 2009 discussion, 2009 screenshots, 2007, 2006, 2006, 2004
_____________________________________________________________________
Big banks in the holiday spirit
(rated 1 to 5 bulbs)
PNC: 12 Days of Christmas index (23 Dec. 2010, 1:00 PM Pacific)
Quick take: Rotating spot, prominent, seasonal graphics, unique, leads to microsite
Score:
TD Bank: gift cards
Quick take: Prominent spot, not rotating, seasonal graphics, fits in well with entire green homepage
Score:
Regions: gift cards and rewards
Quick take: Rotating spot, prominent, seasonal graphics, small corner graphic
Score:
Fifth Third: gift cards
Quick take: Rotating spot, prominent, seasonal graphics, small graphic in upper right
Score:
Bank of the West (BNP Paribas): POP Money (p2p payments)
Quick take: The first promotion on a three-ad rotation, pushes P2P payments as a holiday gift-giving option, the first time we’ve seen that (updated 12/25 because we missed it the first time we looked at the site)
Score:
Harris (BMO): gift card
Quick take: Rotated with five spots, seasonal graphic, quick animation, not very prominent
Score:
ING Direct: seasonal graphic
Quick take: Seasonal graphic, prominent location, leads to landing page
Score:
Chase: gift cards
Quick take: Small ad, minor seasonal graphics
Score:
Key Bank: gift card
Quick take: Prominent position with no rotation, no seasonal graphic
Score:
Bank of America: cash rewards card
Quick take: Small ad with seasonal graphic
Score:
The scrooge list (top-20 banks with no holiday promotions or graphics on Dec. 23):
BB&T, Capital One, Citibank, Citizens (RBS), Comerica, HSBC, SunTrust, Union Bank (Mitsubishi UFJ), US Bank, Wells Fargo
—————————–
Note: I either have accounts with, and/or previous visits to, all 20 banks which could alter what’s shown on the homepage.
The 12 Days of Mobile Banking
In the holiday spirit, I thought I’d lay out the perfect mobile banking/payments app for 2011 (note 1). These are the features I hope to be using on my smartphone at this time next year:
Security
- Option to log in with 4-digit PIN only
- Authorize unusual and/or declined card transactions and unusual checks presented for payment
Bank account management
- Banking data presented in order of importance with new transactions in bold (like Gmail Priority Inbox, previous post)
- Quick view of current balance with predicted balance going forward based on known upcoming transactions
Paper management
- Deposit paper checks via camera (remote deposit)
- Pay bills by taking a picture of the billing statement (photo bill pay)
- Scan-and-store paper receipts and statements
Payments
- Use NFC or bar-codes at the point of sale to make payments directly via phone, without the plastic
- Pay bills or individuals via their mobile phone number
Alerts & calculators
- Receive important alerts via push messages to the phone’s main screen
- Take action or adjust alert sensitivity by responding to messages via text messaging or within the app
- Key financial calculators, such as loan/mortgage payments
And a partridge in a pear tree.
Enjoy the real thing here:
————————
Notes:
1. I’m missing important features, but I had to stop at 12 to fit the holiday theme. Thanks for bearing with me.
2. For more info on mobile banking, see our previous Online Banking Reports.
3. Photo credit: Apple holiday promotion in United Kingdom <itunes12daysofchristmas.co.uk>
The Power of the Recognition
Everyone likes to be recognized for being a loyal customer. It cuts across all demographics and income levels.
Banks and card issuers, which have some of the most loyal customers in any industry, generally do little to reach out and thank long-time customers.
In my wallet, American Express, Discover, Wells Fargo, Chase and Bank of America imprint “member since” on their plastic credit cards. But that’s about the extent of the recognition for holding a long-time account with card issuers, sometimes as long as 20 years.
In the pre-Internet days, it was expensive to create custom marketing programs for specific segments. But today, with the cost of communicating to online customers essentially zero, you should be sending messages to your customers at least once each year, thanking them for their continued business.
And on the bigger milestones, 5 years, 10 years, and so on, send something a little extra. It doesn’t have to be expensive. Find a special perk and offer an “upgrade” on their anniversary. It could be as simple as a 2-for-1 night at the movies, or as exotic as the recently launched PayPal Advantage program (previous post).
Even though the QPB message (below) I received last week was more of last-minute holiday shopping come-on than a loyalty reward, the subject of the email was irresistible and would work well for banking customers:
You’ve Been Upgraded!
Customer email from Quality Paperback Book Club (17 Dec. 2010)
Last Chance for Early Registration Tickets to FinovateEurope — Act Now to Save £100!
The deadline to get your early registration ticket to the upcoming FinovateEurope is this Wednesday, December 22nd.
Buying your ticket
before the end of December 22nd will get you a £100 discount and it will also ensure your attendance
at the event. We had capacity crowds at the last two Finovate
conferences and ticket sales are strong for this event as well.
The conference (February 1 in London) is shaping up phenomenally with three dozen great fintech companies scheduled to demo their latest fintech innovations on stage:
|
|
If you’d like to attend the event and watch the future of European fintech debut on stage, you’ll be joining executives from organizations like Santander, Deutsche Bank, PayPal, Forrester, CIBC, TSYS, Microsoft, Accel Partners, Rabobank, ING, BBVA, Standard Chartered, PostFinance, Raiffeisenbank, Celent and many more.
We hope to see you in February in London!
FinovateEurope 2011 is sponsored by: BlueRock Consulting, Microsoft, Santander, Sapient & The Bancorp
FinovateEurope 2011 is partners with: 154 Consulting, BankerStuff, BankInnovation.net, Banking Automation Bulletin, CardWeb, Filene, Finance on Windows, The Financial Services Innovation Centre, PYMNTS.com & theStartup.eu.