Back to Blog

June Online Financial Services Scorecard from Compete

Compete June scorecard

In April, we introduced the Financial Services Monthly Performance scorecard produced by Compete. It summarizes the overall performance of 23 large U.S. financial institutions and lead-generation sites. Refer here for the detailed methodology as well as companies tracked. 

Overall June highlights:

  • Traffic of financial shoppers was up across all product types except high-yield savings which dropped 2%.
  • More important, applications were up across all products ranging from 3% in savings to 26% in mortgage refinance.
  • A total of 2.9 million product applications were booked; 200,000 more than the 2.7 million last month.

Specific financial institution performance:

  • Bank of America improved its credit card conversion rates dramatically, booking a 30% increase in applications despite only 10% growth in shopping traffic.
  • In checking accounts ING Direct, WaMu, and Wells Fargo all increased the volume of prospects looking at checking account options. 
  • Emigrant, HSBC and ING Direct were all able to increase application volumes despite a flat or declining volume of potential prospects.
  • Home equity prospect traffic grew at 12 of 16 providers and conversion rates were improved at 10 of 16. Bank of America, Citibank, Countrywide and Low.com had the largest month-over-month percentage gains in both prospect and application volume (note 1). 
  • In home-purchase mortgages, Low.com nearly doubled its prospect traffic compared to May, while significantly improving lead conversion.
  • In mortgage refinance, Low.com also posted the largest percentage gain in prospects but grew applications at a lower rate, resulting in a significant decline in conversion. Quicken Loans showed greater efficiency, almost doubling application volume with roughly the same number of prospects as in May.

Note:

1. For loan products, leads from lead-generation sites such as Low.com are combined with actual applications at financial institutions into a single "lead/application" category shown in the table.