2015 Digital Banking Strategic Planning (Part 1)

imageI was on a call today with the digital strategy committee of a large U.S. bank. It was clear from their line of questioning that they are grappling with how to prioritize among the many major opportunities on the digital side.

I won’t list any of the specific topics here, but you could guess most of them (though one would surprise you I think). But the conversation got me thinking about what I’d recommend for next year if I was working in a bank, credit union or consumer fintech company.

In semi-prioritized fashion, here are my first three recommendations for 2015. More will follow.

_______________________________________

1. Insurance
_______________________________________

How are you going to replace NSF fee income once the CFPB gets around to capping it? (Timing hint: There’s a big election in 27 months.) One place to look: Insurance. It’s one of the last frontiers for retail banks, especially in the United States. FinovateSpring 2014 alum Insuritas (demo here) says it can launch your very own insurance store within 90 days. So if you move fast enough, you could have this running by end of year.

______________________________________

2. Lifetime transaction archives
__________________________________

I believe digital services will increase bank loyalty two or three-fold. So instead of accounts turning over every 7 years or so, it will be 15 or 20 years for digital-first households. Why? Once banks come to their senses and start archiving all your transactions like Google does for email, it will be much more of a pain to move.

________________________________________

3. Subscription fees
___________________________________

Back to the Gmail example. How much could Google charge me now that I have 100,000 messages archived there? $100/year easy. Probably more. Banks should be thinking the same way. Get #2 done, then charge $4.95/mo for a Peace of Mind package that includes lifetime archives, mobile document/receipt capture, priority customer service, and so on.  

 

To be continued………..

New Online Banking Report Published: 2013 Guide to Remote Banking Products, Marketing & Strategy

image Alright everyone, take a deep breath, summer is over and it’s time to get down to business. You are now officially behind on all the 2012 “stretch goals” that still seemed possible a few months ago.

And for many, September marks marks the beginning of the 2013 planning cycle. We are here to help. First, we moved FinovateFall up three weeks (to Sep 12/13) so you have more time to get those new ideas in to your plans.

Then there’s our annual reference, OBR’s 2013 Online/Mobile Banking Planning Guide. It’s a thorough resource for financial institution product/marketing managers prioritizing next year’s remote-banking efforts.

The latest version was posted online last night. 

______________________________________________

About the report
______________________________________________

2013 Product, Pricing & Strategy Guide for Remote Banking (link)
Embracing new business models for a digital world

Author: Jim Bruene, Editor & Founder

Published: 29 Aug 2012

Length: 76 pages (36,000 words)

Cost: No extra charge to OBR subscribers, $595 for others here

______________________________________________

Table of Contents

The report contains a list of every idea that has appeared in Online Banking Report or this blog (sample page, below). There are more than 1,000 possible online/mobile tactics listed in the current report, divided into the following categories:

1. Product tacticsclip_image002
A. Checking & transaction cards
B. Deposits & savings
C. Loans & credit
D. Personal finance management
E. Insurance
F. Investing
G. Payments & transfers
H. Mobile services
I. Family (children, teens, tweens)

2. Sales & marketing tactics
A. Increase online sales
B. Selling behind the password
C. Enter new markets & segments
D. Attract new residents (movers)
E. Increase referrals and word-of-mouth
F. Social media and Web 2.0
G. PR: appeal to community

3. Service, security & retention tactics
A. Increase satisfaction levels
B. Enroll more online banking users
C. Encourage/reward self-service
D. Encourage paperless adoption
E. Address security concerns

4. Small business products and services

5. Pricing: Fees and subscriptions

6. Messages & alerts

_________________________________________________

New Online Banking Report Published: 2012 Guide to Remote Banking Products, Marketing, & Strategy

It’s 479 days, 2 hours and 54 minutes until the end of the Mayan calendar* and you know what that means? Yep, it’s time to start putting together your 2012 business and marketing plans. imageAnd don’t think that the end of the world is any excuse to hold back. 

As usual, we’ve got your back. Announcing OBR’s 2012 Online/Mobile Banking Planning Guide. Its goal: to provide a resource for financial institution managers (product and/or marketing) to help prioritize potential remote-banking projects for the coming year.

The latest version was released just this afternoon.

______________________________________________

About the report
______________________________________________

2012 Product, Pricing & Strategy Guide for Remote Banking (link)
Preparing for the mobile-first future

Author: Jim Bruene, Editor & Founder

Published: 29 Aug 2011

Length: 76 pages

Cost: No extra charge to OBR subscribers, $695 for others here

_______________________________________________

 

The report contains a list of every idea that has appeared in Online Banking Report or this blog. There are more than 1,000 possible tactics listed in the current report, divided into the following categories:

1. Product tactics
A. Checking & transaction cards
B. Deposits & savings
C. Loans & credit
D. Personal finance management
E. Investments & insurance
F. Payments & transfers
G. Mobile banking/payments
H. Family (children, teens, tweens)

2. Online sales tactics
A. Increase online sales
B. Selling behind the password
C. Enter new markets & segments
D. Attract new residents (movers)
E. Increase referrals and word-of-mouth
F. Social media and Web 2.0
G. PR: appeal to community/shareholders

3. Service, security & retention tactics
A. Increase satisfaction levels
B. Enroll more online banking users
C. Encourage/reward self-service
D. Encourage paperless adoption
E. Address security concerns

4. Small business

5. Fee-based planner

6. Messages & alerts

——————————————————–

*We don’t want to feed into the Mayan calendar hysteria, but you might want to pick up these super cool keychains here.

New Online Banking Report Published: 2011 Guide to Online & Mobile Products, Pricing & Strategy

Washington new years license plateIn case you hadn’t looked at your calendar, it’s Q4 everyone.  Time to sharpen your pencil, fire up your spreadsheet and create that glorious semi-fictional piece of work, the business plan.

And we at Online Banking Report are on your side. That’s why every year we put every online/mobile idea we can think of into our Annual Planning Guide for Online & Mobile Banking.

Online Banking Report 2011 Planning Report coverThis year, it’s 84 pages long with a thousand or so possible tactics, tips, and strategic endeavors for your online and mobile services. But we don’t make you wade through all 1,000 to find the six you need. The ideas are separated into three buckets:

  • Best practices (5% of total): Must-have features to maintain parity with the competition
  • Best tactics for competitive advantage (25% of total): Ideas that will help you stand out from the pack and/or drive incremental revenue/profit
  • The rest (70% of total): Every company has different strengths and weaknesses; these tactics could be perfect for you

And we’ve also taken our favorite 20 and isolated them in their own section. Here is their alpha order:

  • Activity dashboard/ticker
  • Archives, long-term  
  • Automatic alert enrollment
  • Blog/Twitter and other social media
  • Credit score/report zone
  • Email channel
  • Home equity center
  • In-statement merchant ads
  • Lending center
  • Micro/small-business services
  • Native mobile app (iPhone/Blackberry/Android)
  • Personal finance functionality 
  • Premium/VIP online services
  • Prepaid/gift cards
  • Retirement planning center
  • Student banking/financial education center
  • Text (SMS) banking
  • Transaction streaming
  • Ultra transparent (flat fee) mortgages
  • Usage-based contests/rewards

 

About the report:

———————————————————————————————-

2011 Product, Pricing & Strategy Guide for Online & Mobile Banking (link)
Will online banking fees make a comeback?

Author: Jim Bruene, editor & founder

Published: 30 Sep. 2010

Length: 84 pages

Cost: No extra charge to OBR subscribers, $695 for others here

———————————————————————————————-

New Online Banking Report Published: 2010 Guide to Online & Mobile Products, Pricing & Strategy

imageBelieve it or not, there are just 23 business days left before Q4 2009. That means planning season is just around the corner. To help ease the pain, we offer you the ultimate idea-generation tool; our 15th annual Planning Guide for Online & Mobile Banking.  

imageThe 80-page report is packed with more than 500 product and marketing tactics designed to help you generate new ideas, plans, and strategies for 2010 and beyond.

Online Banking Report subscribers, may download it (here) free of charge. Others may purchase it (here).

Note: Yes, that’s USAA’s awesome native iPhone app on the cover. Mobile banking, specifically via the iPhone and text messaging, are top opportunities for next year.  See below.

  Twenty projects from the report were selected for our 2010 hot list (in alpha order):

  • Activity dashboard/ticker
  • Archives, long term  
  • Automatic alert enrollment
  • Blog/Twitter and other social media
  • Credit score/report zone
  • Friends-and-family loan facilitation
  • High-yield online savings/checking
  • Home equity center
  • Micro/small-business services
  • Native mobile app (iPhone/Blackberry/Android)
  • Personal finance functionality 
  • Premium/VIP online services
  • Prepaid/gift cards
  • Problem mortgage resource center
  • Retirement planning center
  • Service standards/guarantees for online/mobile interactions
  • Student banking/financial education center
  • Text (SMS) banking
  • Ultra transparent (flat fee) mortgages
  • Usage-based contests/rewards

Reference: Media Categories for Delivering Bank & Credit Union Marketing Messages

image I was reading Currency Marketing (note 1) founder Tim McAlpine’s ten-part blog opus (here) on so-called Challenge Marketing, a mix of social media, sweepstakes and viral marketing. It’s great reading, especially if you are thinking of embarking on a new-media marketing campaign.

In part 4, Tim created a list of media available for marketing messages. I started with his list, added to it, and rearranged the topics. Use this as a cheat sheet in your planning meetings to make sure you’ve covered all the bases. I know I’ve missed things, please add to the comments and I’ll update the list.

  • ATMs
    • Screens
    • Enclosures
    • Receipts
  • Blogs
    • Posting/commenting on your own blog
    • Guest posts on others
    • Commenting on other blogs
    • Asking for reciprocal blogroll listings
    • Sponsored blog post (tread carefully)
  • Branch
    • Posters
    • Brochures
    • Plasma screens
    • Floor decals
    • Window decals
  • Call center
    • On-hold messages
    • Press 1 for more info on ____
  • Charitable activities
  • Cinema advertising
  • Door-to-door
    • Flyers
    • Conversations
  • Ecommerce
    • Powered by your brand
    • Advertisements on confirmation screens/email receipts
  • Direct mail
    • Postcard
    • Letter
    • Welcome packages
  • Direct-to-desktop computer applications
    • Widgets
    • Toolbars
    • Buttons/alerts
  • E-mail
    • Direct messages to house or rented list
    • Advertisements/sponsorships within third-party email letters
    • Advertisements within triggered account alerts
  • Joint marketing (with other companies)
  • Mobile
    • Text messages
    • Downloadable app (iphone, Blackberry, Android)
    • Advertising in other apps
    • Sponsoring other apps
    • Featured at carrier/manufacturer site
  • Newsletters
    • Your email/printed/RSS  
    • Third-party properties
  • Online advertising on outside properties
    • Banners and other on-screen ads 
    • Advertorial
    • Sponsorships
    • RSS feed ads
    • Social networks (Facebook, MySpace, MSN, others)
    • Search engines (Google Adwords, Yahoo, Microsoft, others)
  • Online advertising on your properties
    • Main website
    • Online banking site
    • Logon/logoff splash screens
    • Microsites/landing pages
  • Outdoor
    • Billboards
    • Transit
    • Wall projection & other non-traditional outlets
    • Building site signage (construction loan clients)
    • Vehicle signage
  • Print/newspaper/magazine
    • Display ad
    • Classified ad
    • Column/op-ed articles
    • Inserts
    • College and other niche publications
    • Yellow pages/programs/directories/etc.
  • Promotional item giveaways
  • Public relations
    • Appearances and interviews
    • Press releases
    • Spokester (see Currency Marketing’s Young & Free)
  • Radio
    • 15/30 second spot
    • Advertorial
    • Sponsorship
  • Social media activity (note 2)
    • Facebook
    • MySpace
    • LinkedIn
    • Microsoft Live
    • Twitter
    • YouTube
    • Forums
    • Wikis
  • Sponsorships
    • Sports
    • Events
    • Charitable efforts
    • Schools
    • Green efforts
    • Anti-fraud education
  • Statements
    • Stuffers
    • Messages
    • Envelopes
    • Estatement advertising
  • Street-team marketing
  • Sweepstakes (on- and off-line)
  • Telemarketing
  • Third-party locations/publications
    • Advertising/messages
    • Signage
    • WiFi sponsorship
    • Billing statements
    • Websites
    • ATMs/kiosks
  • Television
    • 15/30 second spot
    • Product placement
    • Sponsorship
    • Infomercial
    • Online streams
  • Word of mouth

Notes:
1. Tim McAlpine has achieved near-rock-star status in credit union social media circles as the mastermind of the hugely successful Young & Free campaign.
Update: 18 March 2009, Tim posted a comparison of the latest Y&F campaign at South Carolina Federal Credit Union compared to the original Alberta one. The latest version is up in every category, a partnership with a local radio station is credited with part of the gain.
2. If you need examples from outside banking, here’s a 2-part wiki (here and here) created by social media guru Peter Kim with almost 1000 examples of social media efforts by various brands.

New Online Banking Report Published: 2009 Planning Guide

image With the financial crisis still in full swing, it's not easy to concentrate on the 2009 plan. But focus you must.

You can bet that companies emerging from this mess as winners are working overtime right now, plotting how they will grab your market share next year. Yes, budgets will be down, but thanks to the Web and social media, there are more cost-effective opportunities than ever to get your message out.

With that in mind, we offer the latest issue from Online Banking Report, our 14th annual Planning Guide for Online & Mobile Banking (see note 1).  

It includes 72 pages of ideas, tips and tools to help you generate new ideas, plans, and strategies for 2009 and beyond. Subscribers, Online Banking Report subscribers, may download it (here) free of charge. Others may purchase (here).

While more than 500 online banking product and marketing ideas are published in the report, we hand-selected 20 projects for the 2009 hot list (in alpha order):

  • Activity ticker
  • Balance conversions
  • Credit score/report zone
  • Flat-fee mortgage
  • Green banking
  • High-yield deposit accounts
  • Home equity center
  • iPhone/Android native app
  • Long-term archives
  • Micro/small-business services
  • Peer-to-peer loan facilitation
  • Personal finance functionality 
  • Premium/VIP online services
  • Prepaid/gift cards
  • Problem mortgage resource center
  • Retirement center
  • Service standards/guarantees
  • Social media/blogging
  • Usage-based contests/rewards
  • Widgets

Note:
1. The Netbanker blog (established 2004) and Online Banking Report (established 1994), are written and published by the same company.

Six Steps to the Big Idea of Effective Planning

A crucial part of the planning process is reaching deeply to find the
best ideas. Many companies already have a process in place, but if you are
looking for inspiration, consider the following six-step approach.

Six Steps to the Big Idea

1.       Do Your Homework (Immersion): Study the situation, visit
competitors, read new research, talk to customers, interview employees,
attend a conference, poll your customer base, and so on.

2.       Optimize the Environment: Clear away constraints to
thinking, go off site, stockpile the food and coffee, play music; do
whatever it takes to let your thoughts flow freely.

3.       Rattle the Brain: Perform “thinking exercises” to
limber up the brain before tackling your specific problem (see our ideas,
left, or Jump Start Your Brain by Doug Hall for 37 more).

4.       Generate Idea Nuggets (free form): Think of every
possible solution to the problem, regardless of how crazy; write them down
without judgments or justifications.

5.       Assemble Idea Nuggets Into Strategies and Tactics:
Transcribe each nugget on a
3×5 card and arrange the cards into bigger concepts and ideas.

6.       Be Bold: Don’t immediately dismiss strategies that seem
too big for your budget; winners
could be shopped to strategic investors or other financial institutions for
additional funding.

Source: Adapted from Jump Start Your Brain by Doug Hall, Warner
Books, 1995. A new version, Jump Start Your Business Brain was
published in Sept. 2001. Both are available in paperback from Amazon for
about $12 each.


 

Do Your Homework

To see potential opportunities in a new light, look beyond your normal
circle of peers, subordinates, and other industry sources.

1

Observe First-Hand: Find out how consumers really use online
financial services and observe how the services could be improved. For
example:

  •               Enter into a far-reaching conversation with an
    important vendor, preferably in person
  •                Arrange for a classroom of MBA students to debate the
    pros and cons of online services
  •                Attend a focus group on online financial services
  •                Hire a consultant for a brainstorm session
  •                Sponsor focus groups for branch and call center staff
    to discuss serving/selling customers online
  •                Post a short questionnaire on your website; have a
    copy of each response forwarded directly to you (no staff filters)
  •                Issue an RFP (request for proposal) for the
    development of a “next-generation” service
2

Attend an industry conference: Away from the daily grind,
surrounded by the latest technology and bombarded by new ideas: a perfect
prescription for breakthrough thinking. The two biggest U.S. online banking
conferences take place in the fall, the American Banker’s just-completed
Financial Services Technology Forum
and BAI’s Retail Delivery
which will be held next month in Las Vegas.

3

Dive in to third-party research: Grab a few research reports, head
to a quiet table in your favorite coffee shop, and turn off your Blackberry.
Now, really read the whole report, skipping the executive summary
until the very end. Take notes and highlight pertinent pages. At the end of
the day, create your own executive summary with a list of possible action
ideas and questions to share with your team.

4

Commission your own research: Research culled from your own
customers and in-market prospects is infinitely more believable than
national studies. If research budgets are nil, you can still post a short
survey on your Web for next to nothing and have results tomorrow. The data
won’t be applicable to your entire customer base, but it might provide a
number of good ideas and insights.

Or if you’d prefer to take a quick reading of consumer sentiment without tipping
your hand to the competition, consider tapping into the preassembled panels of
Web research companies. At InsightExpress  http://www.insightexpress.com/
 it’s possible to ask 200 consumers what they think of your idea for an
out-of-pocket expense of about $1,500. Questionnaires are easily
composed using online templates, and you’ll have results back within hours. All
results are stored online where you can run your own reports and cross
tabs.                     

2005/2006 Planning for Premium Online Banking

As we discussed last month , there’s a real void in the marketplace when it
comes to premium online banking services. In today’s retail environment,
where you can choose from hundreds of varieties of every product on the
shelf, it’s shocking that Bank of America provides just a single flavor of
online banking to its 11+ million subscribers. Granted, users choose which
features to use, so the service isn’t truly identical for all.

But surprisingly, everyone still pays a single price: $0. For Bank of
America, that price point has been an important and highly visible component
of its strategic branding message. However, we view 100%-free online banking
as a temporary aberration. U.S. banks have had their hands full during the
past few years complying with new regulatory initiatives and fighting
fraudsters from around the globe.

And it’s a relatively recent phenomenon that online banking penetration
has surpassed 20% at many banks. Below that point, there aren’t enough
customers to make a segmented offering profitable. So even though it will
require extensive buyer education, we believe that by this time next year,
at least one, and possible two or three, top-10 U.S. banks will offer
premium online banking options.

The pioneer in this area is Online Resources, which began offering
MoneyHQ, a premium online banking option, late last year. Early
results are mixed. While Online Resources admits that client adoption has
been slower than expected, it is pleased with consumer adoption, which
stands at 9% of bill pay customers across the 45 clients who’ve been live
for at least four months. In total (as of Sep. 29, 2004), 120 clients are
signed, with 90 operational, representing 33% and 25% respectively of
eligible clients.

Strategically, we have no doubt that MoneyHQ is the right
direction, and the 9% initial adoption rate is encouraging. However, it’s
difficult for ORCC’s community bank and credit union clientele to
successfully educate the market on the benefits of premium online banking.
It may take the multi-million dollar advertising budgets of the big players
to really jump-start the service. We should know a lot more as 2005 unfolds.

Jim Bruene, Editor & Founder